Story Sherpa — Mission to Avalon (Floyd trailer, 2026)
Subject: G:\AVALON\New-Avalon\Floyd\Mission to Avalon Trailer-2026.md
Date: 2026-09-04
Engines run, in order:
- Insight Extraction Engine (all applicable sections + mandatory Second Pass)
- StoryBrand 7-Question brief
- 4 Words, 5 Lines (full edition, with the 5-Line Audit)
- Story Analyzer Rubric (all 8 outputs)
Prompt Creation Engine — not run. No model is drafting from this brief yet. Run it when the trailer goes to a generator.
Pre-score inputs
The Rubric requires four inputs before scoring. None were supplied, so they are inferred from the document and its folder, and stated here so the score can be argued with.
| Input | Value used | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Audience persona | A buyer in a pitch room — someone who can green-light or fund, watching to decide whether this world is worth money | The document is a pitch artifact, not a shooting script. It sits beside a second writer’s treatment and a 90-second pitch. |
| Platform | Trailer — a cut, timed piece of marketing, 1:30–2:15 | Title of the file. |
| Time target | 1:50 | House length for a family sci-fi trailer; the sibling treatment in G:\AVALON\New-Avalon\David\M2A Trailer.md runs 1:29. |
| Primary objective | Awareness, then conversion — make a stranger want this film, then make a buyer able to say yes | A trailer’s only job. |
One hero per run. This run centres MONKEY. The action follows him, the arc belongs to him, and he takes the decisive act. The narration centres the children instead — and that split is Finding #1 below, not a thing to average away. A second full pass with the children as collective hero is available and would score differently; ask for it.
Note on fit. The Rubric is a conversion diagnostic built for marketing. A film trailer maps onto it cleanly — Character, Problem, Failure, Success and Kairos all have exact narrative equivalents — but Plan and CTA are partly vestigial. Where the mapping strains, it is marked. No CTA is invented for a film that has none.
ENGINE 1 — INSIGHT EXTRACTION
SECTION 0 — Document Classification
Type: Narrative / Story, with a Hybrid tail.
Scenes 1–4 are narrative. The NOTES section is a series bible in miniature — seven paragraphs of arc, world and theme that belong to a different document type entirely. The two halves are addressed to two different readers.
Highest-signal sections for this type: Cinematic Translation (run first, per the framework’s own note), Story Layer, Hidden Insights, Assumptions, One-Line Wisdom. Lower signal: Contrarian Edge — a treatment argues with an audience’s expectations, not with received wisdom, so that section is thin here and is reported thin rather than inflated.
Not a null case. There is real buried structure, and at least one insight the document is carrying without naming.
SECTION 9 — Cinematic Translation (moved to front)
Opening scene. Not the wide shot of the kennel. The first frame is a small shape with its paws clasped on top of its head, in a cage, in the dark, while five hundred voices scream around it — and it is the only thing in the picture holding still. Everything is screaming. One creature is listening.
Key visual metaphor: the cage that follows you. The story opens in a wire crate in a swamp and, per NOTE 4, ends in an identical wire crate in the cargo hold of the ship that was supposed to be the rescue. The escape is a circle. That single image carries the whole four-act arc, the twist, and the theme, and the writer already has it — it is sitting in the notes instead of on the screen.
Tone / genre. A children’s survival adventure with a horror floor under it. Watership Down staged in the Everglades, ending on a lie. The comedy is real (a monkey slapping himself over a fly), and the comedy is what makes the floor hold — cut it and the piece is unwatchable.
SECTION 1 — Core Truth
Stated thesis (NOTE 7): light against dark, seen against unseen, the promise of Heaven against the reality of hell.
Actual thesis: whoever holds language holds power. Read the picture again. The children have lost their words and bark. The monkey has no words at all. The robots have no words — only gears and clicks. The only fluent voices in the film are a narrator the characters cannot hear and, per the notes, a corporation that files these children as inventory. “Use your words” is the most loaded line in the document, and it is spoken by a child who barely has any, to a child who has fewer.
The document keeps touching this and never says it. It is the strongest thing in the piece.
Why the document exists: to get someone to pay for Mission to Avalon. It is solving a funding problem, not a story problem — and it is built as though the reader will be patient. A buyer is not patient.
SECTION 2 — Hidden Insights
1. The film is about counting. It opens on a number: “Five hundred, eighty-two animals in all.” NOTE 4 ends on a hold full of cages. Between those two counts, a child is taken out of the count and put back in. Inventory is the horror. The number does exposition that no line of narration can do — say 582 and the audience already knows these are stock, not children.
2. The boots are a complete character arc, unremarked. The children get boots at the escape — the one new thing in their wardrobe, called out in the text. The bots strip the boots at the capture. They finish the escape barefoot. Nobody says a word about it. That is the best-written thing in the document and it happens in the margins. The girl who put her flowered boots on the wrong feet should be the last image of Scene 3: an empty pair, wrong-footed, in the mud.
3. The climax is a spectacle the hero cannot see. In “Look to the Sky”, every character looks up and beholds the Wheel. Monkey is blind. Nobody noticed. This is either the biggest hole in the piece or its best shot: hold on Monkey, alone, facing the wrong way, ears up — the only one in the film who is hearing what heaven sounds like while everyone else stares. Give it to him.
4. The narrator speaks the villain’s diagnosis in his own voice. “Impurity in their blood — the genes are broken.” That is the language of whoever built the kennel, delivered unquoted, by the film. NOTE 1 then describes the children’s impairments in clinical detail. The intent is clearly tender. The framing is not. Put those words in the mouth they belong to — a placard on the cage, a recorded corporate voice, a bot’s readout — and the same sentence becomes an indictment instead of a verdict. This is a one-shot fix with a large downside if skipped.
5. Two rescues, inverted. In Scene 2 the boys go back through the muck for the monkey. In Scene 3 the monkey goes back through the grass for the boys, using the same alligator. Set up, paid off, reversed. That is real structure and the document does not seem to know it did it.
SECTION 3 — Mental Models
The Reciprocal Carry. A rescues B in act one; B rescues A in act three, with the same instrument. Reusable engine for any two-hander where one party looks like a burden. This document runs it once, well, and could run it as the spine.
Inventory Horror. Count the people out loud and the audience supplies the dread themselves. No villain speech required. Cheaper and colder than any monologue.
Impairment Grammar. Every limitation is also an instrument: blind, so he hears; wordless, so he is underestimated; small, so he fits where the others can’t. Cast the disability as the tool and the pity drops out of the story.
The Cut Door. Whoever opens the exit owns the escape. Here, an unseen ally burns the locks with thermite and the children walk through a door someone else made — which is exactly why they are still following someone else’s promised markers two scenes later, and exactly why they collapse when the markers aren’t there.
SECTION 4 — Assumptions
Load-bearing, most dangerous first.
1. That the audience will sit through a full scene of untranslated animal speech. Scene 1 spends its entire dialogue budget on an argument nobody can follow, with no captions. Scene 3 then adds “Translation caption:” — so the rules change halfway through the document. If this assumption is wrong, the film loses the room in its first ninety seconds. This is the collapse point.
2. That “broken genes” reads as the villain’s language. See Hidden Insight 4. If an audience thinks the film agrees with the kennel, no later reversal recovers it.
3. That awe and dread can share the last frame. The trailer ends on children kneeling before the Wheel. The notes say the Wheel is the trap. The document assumes a viewer will hold both. A viewer will not — they will take the last image at its word.
4. That comedy and eugenics can occupy the same scene. A monkey waggles his backside at an alligator four minutes after a narrator explains that these children were caged for impure blood. This can work — it is how the best children’s horror works — but it works only if the film knows it is doing it. Nothing in the document shows that it does.
5. That the reader knows White Fang and Soupy Sales. A 1960s American TV puppet is load-bearing shorthand for the children’s entire vocal performance. Outside one generation, it lands as nothing.
SECTION 5 — Implications
If this is a trailer, almost none of it can be shot. Four fade-ins, a full escape told in order, ~2,300 words of action. Cut to length, this is eight to twelve minutes. Everything else in this analysis is downstream of one decision: is this the trailer, or is it the film’s opening act? They need different documents, and the document currently in the folder is the second one wearing the first one’s name.
The property already has a spine, and it isn’t the swamp. It is inventory. Both
treatments in G:\AVALON\New-Avalon\ reached it independently (see Appendix).
The monkey is the asset. Merchandise, poster, a name the audience can say. He is also the only character in the document with a want, a method and a victory. Every structural problem here gets smaller the moment he is named the hero out loud.
SECTION 6 — Contrarian Edge
Thin, and reported thin rather than manufactured.
One genuine contrarian move: the document trusts an audience to sit with speech it cannot understand. That instinct is right and most notes would sand it off. The correct response is not to soften it but to commit or drop it — untranslated from the first frame to the last, or subtitled from the first word. The half-measure in the current draft is the only version that fails.
SECTION 7 — Actionable Intelligence
- Decide the format before the next draft, because every other note changes based on the answer. Trailer at 1:50, or opening act at eight minutes. Write it at the top of the file.
- Name the hero in the first ten seconds, because a vague hero poisons everything downstream. Open on Monkey. Give him a name the audience can say out loud.
- Move “the genes are broken” into the villain’s mouth, because unquoted, it is the film’s own verdict on disabled children.
- Set one captioning rule and hold it for the whole picture, because changing it mid-document tells a buyer the rule hasn’t been decided.
- Stop narrating what the picture shows. Cut “The idea was inspired by the rock that hit him in the head” and shoot the rock: he picks it up, feels it, turns his ears toward the alligators.
- Cut the C.S. Lewis quotation, because a borrowed sentence at the moment of maximum image tells the audience the image was not enough. If the faith frame is the point, stage it — do not cite it.
- Put a cage in the boarding bay, because the story’s own notes say the Wheel is the trap and the trailer currently advertises it as salvation.
- Move the Jurassic Park and Soupy Sales references out of the scene text and into a comps line, because a director’s note inside a scene reads as a copy, not a reference.
- Say the word “Avalon” somewhere in the film. It never appears in the document. Avalon is the island where the wounded king is taken to be healed; these children want healing. The title is doing work the script never claims.
SECTION 8 — Story Layer
- Character: Monkey. Blind, deaf to nothing, caged as vermin, carried when he cannot keep up. Want: to stay with the ones who took him.
- Problem. External: a locked cage in a thousand acres of swamp, then a battalion. Internal: he is the burden, and he knows it — he runs in circles while the others clear the snake. Philosophical: a world that files its damaged children as stock and ships them out.
- Guide: absent by design, and that is the good version. Someone off-screen burns the locks and promises markers that never appear. The guide fails, and the hero has to become one. Monkey leads at the end, blind, bumping into trees.
- Transformation: cargo → guide. The thing that had to be carried does the carrying.
- Stakes: the cage, and a second cage after it that looks like a rescue.
SECTION 10 — One-Line Wisdom
Three candidates:
- “The one they almost left behind is the one who hears it coming.”
- “A world that calls its children broken has already told you what it plans to do with them.”
- “Every escape story is really about who gets carried.”
Selected: #3. It has the turn, it is true for someone who has never read the document, and it names the mechanism the piece is actually built on — the boys carry the monkey out of the swamp, the monkey carries the boys out of the trap. #2 is sharper about this story but only works if you know the story. #1 is a tagline, not a truth.
SECOND PASS (mandatory)
1. What did I miss on the first pass? The silence. Twice the document stops dead — “Time stops. For a long moment, the only sounds are the crickets, night bugs, and the escape alarms” and “The world freezes. Then pandemonium.” Both are the best-directed moments in the piece, and both work through a blind character’s sense. The film has a sound design thesis it has not noticed it has: when the picture stops, we hear what Monkey hears. That is the device that makes him the hero without a line of dialogue, and it costs nothing.
2. What is the deepest insight — the most load-bearing? Not the language thesis, which is the most interesting. The load-bearing one is Hidden Insight 3: the climax is a reveal the hero cannot see. Every other note here is a fix. That one is a decision about what the film is. If Monkey is the hero, “Look to the Sky” is the wrong ending for him and has to be re-staged. If the children are the heroes, then Scene 3 — the whole battle, won single-handed by the monkey — belongs to a supporting character, and the arc has no climax. The document cannot have both, and it has not chosen.
3. Where is it most vulnerable? Assumption 1 — the untranslated first scene. If that is wrong, nothing downstream matters, because nobody is still watching.
4. Did I manufacture depth? Section 6 (Contrarian Edge) yields almost nothing here and is reported at its true weight rather than padded. Section 3’s fourth model (The Cut Door) is real but is sharpened by comparison with the sibling treatment rather than drawn purely from this document — it is flagged rather than dressed up as native.
5. What changes if I explain this to the author’s smartest critic? I would drop the format complaint to second place. A defender would say: this is a treatment, everyone in the room knows a trailer gets cut later, stop scoring a document for the title on its file. That is fair. So the argument has to stand on the parts that hold at any length — the hero is unchosen, the last image contradicts the story, and the narrator uses the villain’s vocabulary. Those three are true whether this runs 1:50 or eight minutes. The rest is packaging.
ENGINE 2 — STORYBRAND 7-QUESTION BRIEF
Run once, hero = Monkey. Answers are written as the brief the trailer should satisfy, with the document’s current state noted against each.
| # | Question | The brief |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Character / goal | Monkey wants to stay with the ones who took him — to be worth carrying. Current state: unstated; the narration’s hero is a nameless flock. |
| 2 | Problem | External: a locked cage inside a thousand acres of swamp, then a battalion of wranglers between him and the only people who ever came back for him. Internal: he is the burden and he knows it — he can’t clear the snake, he runs in circles while the jaws open. Philosophical: no one gets filed as stock for the shape they were born in. Current state: all three present, but the philosophical level is asserted in narration and never staged. |
| 3 | Guide | There is no guide. Someone burned the locks and promised markers that were never there. Empathy: the film knows what it is to be the one who slows everybody down. Authority: he hears what is coming before anything else in the picture does. Current state: the failed guide is a good choice, well executed. Monkey’s authority is established late — the ears do not pay off until Scene 3. |
| 4 | Plan | Three steps, all his: taunt them, break their line, run. Current state: present and clear in Scene 3 — but told after the fact, in narration, and preceded by an anti-plan (“There is a plan. Maybe. No one really knows if it’ll work”). |
| 5 | CTA (narrative equivalent: the emotional ask) | Direct: look up. Transitional: listen. The film’s ask of the audience is to believe the thing that cannot see is the thing that knows. Current state: the ask is delivered as instruction — the narration explains the metaphor while the image is still on screen. |
| 6 | Failure | Recapture. Boots stripped, marched back down the trail, filed again — and the second cage looks like a rescue. Current state: the strongest element in the document. Staged, not stated. Do not touch it. |
| 7 | Success | Status: the burden becomes the guide — the blind one leads. Inner Peace: somebody came back for him, and now he is somebody who comes back. Completeness: they are out. Current state: Completeness only, and it is a false one — the film’s own notes say the Wheel is the next cage. |
Brief-stage verdict: Character, Problem and Success can all be answered, so the script is writable. But answering them required reading the notes and the subtext, not the trailer. If a stranger cannot extract these seven answers from the cut, the cut is not doing the brief’s job.
One-liner (StoryBrand formula — Problem / Solution / Success): Five hundred and eighty-two creatures are caged for the way they were born. The smallest and blindest of them is the only one who can hear the way out. When the markers turn out to be a lie, the burden becomes the guide.
ENGINE 3 — 4 WORDS, 5 LINES (full edition)
Pre-step — audience
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| Primary audience | One buyer in one room, deciding whether this world is worth money. Written for that person, not averaged with the eventual ticket-buyer. |
| Current state of belief | Uninformed and slightly braced. They have read a lot of “young heroes escape a dystopia” this year. |
| Platform | A cut trailer, watched once, probably on a laptop, probably with something else open. |
THE 4 WORDS — how the document scores as a posture
BREVITY — weak. ~2,300 words of action for a form that lives on 200. Scene 3 restarts on the image it just left (“MONKEY sits atop a rock. Listening.”). The dialogue is transcribed twice. The camera choreography in Scene 2 — track right, dolly out, drone past, reframe — is a shot list living inside a pitch. Can you cut 20% without losing meaning? You can cut 60%.
LEVITY — strong, and the document’s best asset. The fly slap and the check of the empty paw. The fanny waggle. “Jabbering bad words … in Monkey.” The girl who put her flowered boots on the wrong feet. Four bridges, spread evenly, all of them earning the harder material around them. Protect these in every rewrite. They are the permission structure that lets an audience stay in a film about caged children.
CLARITY — weak. The enemy of clarity is the hedge, and the document hedges at its most important moment: “There is a plan. Maybe. No one really knows if it’ll work, though.” Add the captioning rule that changes halfway through, “dualy eye-patched”, WRANGLER BOTS becoming WRANGLE BOTS, and a scene direction that cites Jurassic Park, and the reader is doing work the writer should have done.
CHARITY — mixed. The film serves its audience generously in image and denies them in structure: no logline, no length, no comps line, no statement of what this document is. A reader has to reverse-engineer the pitch. Own the confusion — one header block fixes it.
THE 5 LINES — written for this piece
1. OUTLINE (Excite → Disturb → Assure, one sentence per act)
- Act 1 — Excite: In a swamp full of cages, the only creature not screaming is a blind monkey who can hear everything.
- Act 2 — Disturb: The children break out and carry him with them, and then the swamp, the machines and their own despair take everything back — the boots off their feet included.
- Act 3 — Assure: The one they carried starts a war he cannot see, wins it with his ears, and leads them up a hill toward a light that is not what any of them think it is.
Written as a promise, not a table of contents. The act-3 line withholds the Wheel.
2. HEADLINE
- Hook-led (12 words): “The children can’t talk. The monkey can’t see. Together they get out.”
- Transformation-led (13 words): “They carried him out of the swamp. Then he carried all of them.”
Both survive a forward with no context. The document currently has no headline at all — no logline, no tagline, nothing a reader can repeat.
3. FRONT LINE (the cold open — written last, as the framework requires)
Black, and five hundred animals screaming at once. Then one cage, and one small creature holding perfectly still with his paws clasped on his head, listening — because he is the only thing in this place that already knows something is coming.
Cut test: does the Headline land without this? No — the whole claim rests on the audience meeting the ears before it meets the plot. Keep it. Everything else in the current Scene 1 opening (the thousand acres, the alligators, the grease-water) is scenery and can arrive underneath the card.
4. BOTTOM LINE (two functions, written separately)
- Hero Emotional Close: “Nobody ever taught them their names. Nobody ever taught him to see. They got each other out anyway.”
-
Guide Credibility Anchor:
[PLACEHOLDER — needs a real fact]— the line that says who is making this and why they can be trusted to make it. Format, running time, comps, and whatever the team has actually shipped before. Nothing is invented here; supply the facts and the line writes itself.
Kairos — the reason it must be now: the Wheel is boarding. It is in the document’s own last scene and never named as a clock. Say it, once, at the top of Act 3: the sky is leaving. Miss it and the only thing left is the trail back to the kennel.
5. SIDE LINE — [PLACEHOLDER — needs a real fact]
The line only Floyd can say. There is something personal in this story — the eye patches painted with rainbows and cartoon eyeballs, the mechanical knee brace, the girl whose feet curve out, called “cute, goofy” rather than sad. That detail was not invented by someone with no stake in it. Ask him what it is, and put it in the pitch. It cannot be manufactured here and it is the difference between this pitch and every other caged-children pitch in the pile.
THE 5-LINE AUDIT — the document as it stands
| Line | Mapped to | Present? | Weight |
|---|---|---|---|
| Outline | Four titled scenes, sequenced cage → escape → battle → revelation | ✅ | Legible, but Act 4 runs 200 words against Act 2’s 900 |
| Headline | Nothing. No logline, no tagline, no repeatable claim | ❌ | The largest single omission in the document |
| Front Line | The kennel wide shot, then the track in to the monkey | ⚠️ | The right subject, buried under ~500 words of scenery |
| Bottom Line — Hero Emotional Close | “Looking to the sky, the Fugitives … find the solution they’ve been looking for” | ⚠️ | Ends on a fact, not a feeling — and on a fact the notes contradict |
| Bottom Line — Guide Credibility Anchor | Nothing | ❌ | No title card, no format, no comps, no maker |
| Side Line | The impairment details in NOTE 1 | ⚠️ | Present in the notes, absent from the pitch |
Anything that maps to none of the five is redundant or premature. By that test, the camera choreography in Scene 2, the second “Monkey sits atop a rock”, the Soupy Sales note and the Jurassic Park note are all premature — they belong to a shooting document, not this one.
ENGINE 4 — STORY ANALYZER RUBRIC
Mode 2 — Post-Draft Diagnostic. Hero: Monkey. Platform calibration: trailer, scored against the Social (B) column for Brevity and Kairos, Live Stage (D) for Pathos and Levity.
OUTPUT 1 — Executive Snapshot
DIAGNOSIS: The document films one hero and narrates a different one, then ends on an image its own notes call a lie — so the strongest character in the piece never gets an arc and the last frame sells the villain.
FIX 1: Name Monkey the hero in the first ten seconds and re-stage “Look to the Sky” so the blind one is not asked to behold anything — hold on him, facing away, ears up, hearing what heaven sounds like while everyone else stares.
FIX 2: Put a cage in the boarding bay. One shot, three frames, in the last ten seconds — the same wire crate from the kennel, sitting in the light under the Wheel. The trailer currently advertises the trap as the rescue.
FIX 3: Move “impurity in their blood — the genes are broken” out of the narrator’s voice and into the villain’s — a placard, a recording, a bot’s readout — and cut the C.S. Lewis quotation entirely. The film is currently speaking the kennel’s language about disabled children in its own voice, and explaining its theme in a borrowed sentence.
OUTPUT 2 — Scorecard with Heatmap
StoryBrand 18/35 ❌ Character ✅ Problem★★ ⚠️ Guide ⚠️ Plan
⚠️ CTA★★ ✅ Failure ⚠️ Success★★
PDS 10/15 ⚠️ Excite ✅ Disturb ⚠️ Assure
9 Principles 18/35 ⚠️ Clarity★★ ⚠️ Brevity ⚠️ Charity ✅ Levity
❌ Headline ⚠️ Bottom Line ⚠️ Outline
Rhetoric 8/15 Pathos heavy / Logos thin / ❌ Ethos absent / ⚠️ Kairos lit once, then dropped
─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
TOTAL 54/100
Element detail:
| Element | Pts | Mark | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Character ★ | 2 | ❌ | Two heroes, neither chosen. The named characters are “BOY 1” and “GIRL 1”. Nobody in this film has a name — including, per the narration, themselves. |
| Problem ★★ | 4 | ✅ | All three levels present, which is rare. Docked one: philosophical stakes are asserted in VO, never staged. |
| Guide | 2 | ⚠️ | The failed off-screen guide is a strong choice. Monkey’s authority arrives too late to pay off. |
| Plan | 2 | ⚠️ | A clear three-beat plan in Scene 3, narrated after the fact, preceded by an explicit anti-plan. |
| CTA ★★ | 2 | ⚠️ | The emotional ask exists but is explained rather than earned. No transitional equivalent — nothing tells a viewer what this is or what comes next. |
| Failure | 4 | ✅ | Jaws, alarms, capture, boots stripped, marched back. Staged, unsoftened, excellent. Docked one: the real failure (the second cage) is only in the notes. |
| Success ★★ | 2 | ⚠️ | Completeness only, and false. No Status shift, Inner Peace unclaimed. |
| Excite | 3 | ⚠️ | Arresting world, but ~500 words before anything happens and no hero want established. |
| Disturb | 5 | ✅ | Scored strictly and still full marks. The cost of the status quo is on screen, repeatedly. |
| Assure | 2 | ⚠️ | Resolution is a spectacle the notes contradict, closed with a quotation. |
| Clarity ★★ | 2 | ⚠️ | Hedges, a captioning rule that changes mid-document, director’s notes inside scene text, typos. |
| Brevity | 2 | ⚠️ | ~2,300 words for a 1:50 form. Repeats an image and a dialogue pattern. |
| Charity | 3 | ⚠️ | Generous in image, withholding in structure. No header, no length, no logline. |
| Levity | 5 | ✅ | Four genuine bridges, evenly spread, load-bearing. The best-executed principle in the document. |
| Headline | 1 | ❌ | Absent entirely. |
| Bottom Line | 2 | ⚠️ | Hero close ends on fact; credibility anchor missing. |
| Outline | 3 | ⚠️ | Four visible acts, badly proportioned, none written as a promise. |
Reading: 54/100 — partial structure, multiple gaps, rewrite with the rubric as guide.
Read the number carefully. It is a location, not a verdict. This document scores in the fifties because it is answering a different brief than the one on its own title — and because two conversion-critical elements (Character, Headline) are absent, which the rubric punishes hard. The writing itself is not in the fifties. Disturb, Failure and Levity all score full or near-full, and those are the three elements most writers cannot fake.
OUTPUT 3 — Gap Analysis
Directives with line-level targets. Kairos first, always.
1. KAIROS — lit once, then abandoned. It exists exactly once: “In the distance, alarms are now going off at The Kennel. Time’s running out.” Then it vanishes for the remaining two scenes. Add a time-specific trigger at the head of Act 3 and again in the Bottom Line zone. The clock is already in the document and unused: the Wheel is “taking on passengers as well as luggage and supplies.” It is loading. It will leave. Put that on screen before the hill — a plasma sled lifting, a bay door starting to close — and every step up that hill has a deadline under it.
2. ★★ CHARACTER — flag before all others (scores below 3). Rewrite the first ten seconds so the film’s first subject is its hero. Open on Monkey in the cage, alone, before any wide shot. Give him a name that a child can say out loud and put it in the film — the current best candidate is what the boy calls him, which is “Monkey”, and that is a category, not a character. Then choose once and hold it: if Monkey is the hero, Scene 4 must be re-staged around a creature who cannot see the reveal. If the children are the heroes, Scene 3’s single-handed victory has to be shared. The document cannot keep both.
3. ★★ SUCCESS — Status absent, and the Completeness on offer is false. Insert one shot inside the boarding-bay imagery in Scene 4: a wire cage, identical to the kennel’s, standing in the clean light among the luggage and supplies. Hold it for three frames. Nobody looks at it; the audience does. That single insert converts the ending from a promise the story will break into a promise the story is keeping. Then add the Status beat in the same scene: the others kneel, and Monkey — who has been carried, thrown out of a tree, and hit with a rock — walks in front of them, blind, leading.
4. ★★ CTA — the emotional ask is explained instead of earned. Cut the entire “Someone once said, and it applies here” narration block. Replace the third VO block in Scene 4 with silence and one line of image. The narration currently tells the audience that looking up is the point while they are looking up. Add a transitional ask in the end card zone — the trailer equivalent of “not ready to commit”: a title card that tells a buyer what this is (format, running time, what the series is) so the piece converts a reader as well as a viewer.
5. ★★ CLARITY — hedges and a rule that changes mid-document. Delete “There is a plan. Maybe. No one really knows if it’ll work, though.” and replace it with the plan’s actual condition: they were promised markers; there are no markers yet. That is the same information without the shrug. Set one captioning rule in a header line and hold it to the last frame — recommendation below. Move the Jurassic Park note and the Soupy Sales / White Fang note out of the scene text into a comps block at the top. Fix WRANGLE/WRANGLER, “dualy”, “oder”, “the girl’s yowl”, “he utters a one distinguishable word.”
6. HEADLINE — absent (1/5, the largest single point deficit). Add a header block above FADE IN with four lines: logline, format and running time, comps, and tagline. Two headline candidates are supplied in Output 4. Without this, the document arrives in a room unable to say what it is.
7. BREVITY — 2,300 words for a 1:50 form. Cut Scene 2’s camera choreography (track right, dolly out, drone past, reframe) — the reveal survives as three images: parallel trails, the wide of many trails, one bot’s red eyes. Delete the second “MONKEY sits atop a rock. Listening.” — the FADE OUT / FADE IN restarts the scene on the image it just left. Compress Scene 1’s dialogue exchange from eight blocks to three; the argument’s content does not matter, only that it is an argument about whether the monkey comes.
8. GUIDE — authority arrives too late. Plant the ears in Scene 1 and pay them in Scene 2. He is already the one creature holding still while five hundred scream. Add one beat in the swamp where Monkey stops, and a half-second later the others hear what he heard. From then on, when he stops, the audience is afraid — which is the whole engine of Scene 3, running two scenes earlier for free.
9. ASSURE / BOTTOM LINE — ends on a fact, and a borrowed one. Replace the closing narration with the Hero Emotional Close from Engine 3 and put the credibility anchor on the title card. End on feeling. Right now a viewer walking out could tell you what the last scene said and not how it felt.
10. RHETORICAL IMBALANCE — single rebalancing move. Ethos is at zero and Kairos is starved. One move fixes both: a header block plus a title card. Format, running time, comps and a tagline supply the Ethos a pitch document needs; the boarding Wheel supplies the Kairos. Nothing about the story has to change.
OUTPUT 4 — Headline & Bottom Line
Headline — hook-led (12 words):
The children can’t talk. The monkey can’t see. Together they get out.
Headline — transformation-led (13 words):
They carried him out of the swamp. Then he carried all of them.
Both under 20 words, both survive a forward with no context, both repeatable after one reading.
Bottom Line — Hero Emotional Close:
Nobody ever taught them their names. Nobody ever taught him to see. They got each other out anyway.
Bottom Line — Guide Credibility Anchor:
[PLACEHOLDER — needs a real fact]Format, running time, what the series is, who is making it, and any prior work that earns the room’s trust. Supply the facts and this writes itself in one line.
Tagline candidates for the end card:
- THE GENES ARE BROKEN. THE KIDS AREN’T. (38 characters)
- USE YOUR WORDS. (15 characters — taken from the script, and the best of the three)
- HE NEVER SAW IT COMING. HE HEARD IT. (36 characters)
OUTPUT 5 — Refined Script, Four Versions
One story. Four surfaces. Everything below is built from material already in Floyd’s document — the kennel, the count, the barking, “Use your words”, the python, the alligator, the boots, the rock, the fanny waggle, the gears and clicks, the half-dead tree, the hill, the Wheel. Nothing is invented except structure.
Captioning rule, set once and held: in the trailer, subtitle every line from the first word. A trailer has 110 seconds and cannot also teach a language. Save the untranslated immersion for the film’s first act, where it has the room to earn itself. This resolves the rule change between Scene 1 and Scene 3.
VERSION A — PRIMARY (1:50, timed beats, StoryBrand nodes tagged)
EXCITE — 0:00–0:20
0:00 Black. Five hundred animals screaming at once. No music. [CHARACTER]
0:05 One cage. A small capuchin, paws clasped on top of his head, two eye patches,
ears the size of his hands. Everything around him is screaming. He is holding still.
He is listening.
0:11 Pull back, and back: cages stacked six high, red afternoon light, a thousand
acres of grease-water.
0:15 CARD: FIVE HUNDRED AND EIGHTY-TWO ANIMALS. [PROBLEM — philosophical]
0:17 A cage at the end of the row. Behind the wire: a boy. Muddy, barefoot,
barking.
0:19 CARD: SOME OF THEM ARE CHILDREN.
DISTURB — 0:20–1:14
0:20 GIRL, subtitled: “Use your words.” [PROBLEM — internal]
BOY, barking, then one word: “Monkey.”
0:24 A thermite strip eats through a lock. Red light turns green. Doors pop.
[PLAN — someone else's]
0:28 Boots hitting mud. Children running under a full moon. Behind them, blind,
zig-zagging, chasing the sound of the others: Monkey.
0:33 A python crosses the trail, thick as a pipe. The children jump it. Monkey
doesn’t. [FAILURE]
0:37 Alarms, distant, at the kennel. [KAIROS]
0:39 Grass splits. An alligator, locked on. The jaws open.
0:42 Everything stops. Crickets. Night bugs. Alarms. [the film's device — we hear what he hears]
0:45 The boys explode through the muck, barking like mad dogs. One scoops him up.
Monkey tattoos himself to the boy’s head, tail around his neck. [the carry]
0:50 Dawn. A montage of small figures picking their way through the wasteland,
helping each other. Monkey at the rear, sniffing, listening.
0:56 Monkey stops. A half-second later, so does everyone else. [GUIDE — planted]
0:59 The passing tail of an alligator fills the frame. Then a python’s head, on the
parallel trail. Then the wide: a dozen flattened trails, all heading the same way.
1:05 And past them, in a straight line, machines. Gears and clicks. Neon red eyes.
[FAILURE — escalated]
1:09 Under a half-dead tree, the children sit down. One face down. One with her head
on her knees. BOY, subtitled: “No markers. Lie.” GIRL: “Can’t keep going.” BOY:
“Die here.”
1:13 Rice grass parts. The bots are already there.
ASSURE — 1:14–1:44
1:14 Capture sticks. Children dragged out of the branches, stood in a circle,
stripped of their boots. [FAILURE — landed]
1:19 A bot picks up a rock and throws it. Monkey drops out of the tree.
1:22 On the ground. He finds the rock with his hands. Turns it over. Feels the
weight of it. [no VO]
1:25 His ears turn — to the machines marching his friends back down the trail, and
then to the grass, where the trails are still coming. [PLAN — his own]
1:29 He runs. Waves his arms. Makes sure they see him. Aims his backside at the
monsters and waggles it. [LEVITY BRIDGE]
1:33 They detonate. He runs. And a wall of snakes and alligators hits the line of
machines side-on. BOOM. Bots cartwheel. Arms and legs shoot off like rockets.
1:38 Children running barefoot through the wreck. An empty pair of flowered boots
in the mud, wrong feet. [SUCCESS — inner peace]
1:41 A hill. Monkey in front now, leading, blind, bumping into a tree. The others
follow him. [SUCCESS — status]
1:44 They crest the hill. They look up. One by one, they go to their knees.
1:47 Hold on Monkey. Facing the wrong way. Ears up. Hearing what it sounds
like. [the shot the film has been building to]
BUTTON — 1:47–1:50
1:47 The Wheel, six miles of it, silent overhead. Plasma sleds lifting children in
clean molded armor into the ports. And there, in the light, among the luggage and the
supplies — one wire cage. [the trap, three frames]
1:49 CUT TO BLACK.
TITLE: MISSION TO AVALON CARD: USE YOUR WORDS.
In the black: gibberish, then one word, close. “Monkey.”
VERSION B — SOCIAL CUT (25 seconds)
Brevity and Kairos weighted highest. Same ask as Version A.
0:00 Black. Screaming. One cage. One small creature holding still, listening.
0:04 CARD: FIVE HUNDRED AND EIGHTY-TWO ANIMALS. SOME OF THEM ARE CHILDREN.
0:07 Locks burning. Boots in the mud. Barking.
0:10 An alligator’s jaws open on a blind monkey. Silence.
0:12 Boys explode out of the muck and carry him off.
0:15 Machines. Red eyes. Children on their knees, boots stripped.
0:18 The monkey finds the rock that hit him. Turns it over.
0:20 He waggles his backside at an alligator. [LEVITY]
0:21 BOOM. Bots in the air.
0:23 TITLE: MISSION TO AVALON — USE YOUR WORDS.
VERSION C — EXEC / BUYER CUT
Logos and Ethos elevated. Pathos present but second. This is the version the document is currently missing entirely.
Logline. On a world that cages the children it calls broken, five of them break out into a thousand acres of swamp — and when the promised trail out turns out to be a lie, the only one who can find the way is the blind monkey they nearly left behind.
Format. [PLACEHOLDER — needs a real fact] — feature or series, running time,
animation or live action with CG.
Comps. The children’s-adventure floor of Watership Down with the reveal structure of a survival thriller. The Wheel reveal is staged on the Jurassic Park “look up” beat. The children’s speech is built on the White Fang dialect from the Soupy Sales shows — comprehension is optional, intention is not.
Why it holds together commercially. One merchandisable non-verbal lead who
carries the whole third act. A villain with no dialogue and no face — gears and
clicks, red eyes — which is cheap to build and legible in every territory. A
first-act cost that is mostly practical: mud, wire, water, and one animal.
[PLACEHOLDER — needs a real budget shape]
Why now. [PLACEHOLDER — needs a real fact] — the deployment Kairos sits
outside the script and cannot be scored from the document. Supply it: a slate, a
window, a partner, a market.
The turn buyers should be told about, and audiences shouldn’t. The Wheel is not the rescue. The ship has an underworld and a cargo hold full of the same cages they just escaped. The trailer plants it in three frames and never says it. The series is about what they find down there.
Team and track record. [PLACEHOLDER — needs a real fact]
VERSION D — LIVE STAGE (diagnostic master)
Floyd, in a room, no screen. Performance annotations included. If this version holds, every other version can be derived from it. Levity Bridges marked.
“There’s a place in the middle of a thousand acres of swamp where they keep the
animals that didn’t come out right.” [SLOW]
“Five hundred and eighty-two of them. Cats. Dogs. Raccoons. Skunks.” [PAUSE]
“And a small flock of children who have been in there so long they’ve forgotten
their own names.” [PAUSE — let it sit]
“They bark now. That’s how they talk. And there’s one line they all still have, and
they say it to each other, all day long, when the barking gets out of hand —”
[EMPHASIS] “Use your words.”
[AUDIENCE BEAT]
“And in the cage at the end of the row there’s a monkey. Blind. Two eye patches.
Ears like satellite dishes.” [LEVITY BRIDGE — let them enjoy him]
“He’s the only thing in that whole building that isn’t screaming. He’s listening.”
[PAUSE]
“One night, somebody on the outside burns the locks off. The doors pop. The kids run — and they take him with them, because one of them wouldn’t leave without him.”
“Twenty minutes into the swamp, an alligator gets him.” [FAST] “And three boys who
weigh sixty pounds each go back into the water for a monkey.” [PAUSE]
“So now he’s cargo. He’s the one they carry.”
[SLOW]
“They’d been told there’d be markers. A trail. Somebody’s put signs out there to lead
them home.” [PAUSE] “There are no markers. There were never any markers.”
“And about a mile back, following their scent, there are alligators, and snakes, and a line of machines with red eyes that don’t say anything at all — they just click.”
[AUDIENCE BEAT]
“The kids sit down under a dead tree and quit. One of them says — and this is the
whole movie in three words —” [EMPHASIS] “Die here.”
“The machines take them. Stand them in a circle. Take their boots.” [PAUSE]
“And one of the machines picks up a rock and throws it at the monkey in the tree, because he won’t stop yelling.”
[LONG PAUSE]
“He finds that rock on the ground. Turns it over in his hands. Blind. And he works out that if you make something angry enough, it stops looking where it’s going.”
“So he runs out into a field full of alligators — and he insults them.” [LEVITY BRIDGE — this is the laugh, wait for it] “In monkey.”
[AUDIENCE BEAT]
“And then he points them at the machines.”
[FAST] “Ten seconds later there are robot arms coming down out of the sky.”
[PAUSE — full stop, drop the energy]
“The kids walk out of that swamp barefoot. And the one leading them up the hill — in front, bumping into trees — is the one they had to carry in.”
[SLOW]
“At the top of the hill they look up, and there’s a ship. Six miles across. Taking
on children.” [PAUSE] “Every one of them goes to their knees.”
“Except him. He can’t see it.” [PAUSE] “He’s just standing there with his ears
up, listening to what heaven sounds like.”
[LONG PAUSE]
“Nobody ever taught those kids their names. Nobody ever taught him to see. They got each other out anyway.”
[BEAT]
“That’s the trailer. Here’s what I haven’t told you.” [flat, dropped tone] “That
ship has a bottom deck. And the bottom deck is full of cages.”
[STOP]
Version D diagnostic verdict: the story is structurally sound. Told in a room with no pictures, it holds — hero, want, cost, reversal, victory, and a turn at the end. Two laughs land, the despair beat lands, and the ending inverts cleanly. That means the problems in the current document are format and framing problems, not story problems. This is good news and it should be read as the headline of the whole analysis: what is wrong here is fixable in a rewrite, not in a rethink.
OUTPUT 6 — CTA & Plan
Narrative equivalents. A film trailer’s CTA is the emotional ask plus the practical one.
Direct CTA (the audience): Look up. Delivered as image only — the Wheel, the kneeling, and the one creature facing the wrong way. Never spoken.
Transitional CTA (the buyer): the end card. [PLACEHOLDER — needs a real fact]
Format, running time, and where to see more. The lower-commitment ask for a reader
who is not ready to green-light but is ready to keep reading.
The 3-Step Plan — Monkey’s, formatted for the end-card and the pitch:
- Make them angry.
- Point them at the line.
- Run.
Three steps, each an action verb under five words. Read cold, they lower anxiety — which is the test. They also tell a buyer the third act has a shape.
OUTPUT 7 — Rhetorical Mix Readout
Estimated mix (current document):
Pathos 65% (target 50%) +15
Logos 25% (target 30%) -5
Ethos 5% (target 10%) -5
Kairos 5% (target 10%) -5
Heaviest imbalance: Pathos over-weight, Ethos near zero.
Pathos-heavy is closer to correct for a trailer than for a sales deck, so the overage is not the problem. The problem is the two starved elements. Ethos is at 5% because the document contains no logline, no comps line, no format, no running time and no maker — nothing that tells a room this is a real production rather than a good idea. Kairos is at 5% because it is lit once, in Scene 2, and dropped.
Single rebalancing move: add the header block (logline / format / comps / tagline) and name the Wheel’s departure as a clock. One block and one line of image move Ethos and Kairos to target without touching a frame of the story.
OUTPUT 8 — On-Screen Packaging
Lower-thirds (max 40 characters):
-
FIVE HUNDRED AND EIGHTY-TWO ANIMALS.(36) -
SOME OF THEM ARE CHILDREN.(26) -
THERE WERE NEVER ANY MARKERS.(29)
End card:
MISSION TO AVALON USE YOUR WORDS.
[PLACEHOLDER — needs a real fact: format, running time, where to see more]
Thumbnail / hook text (≤45 characters):
-
THE BLIND MONKEY WHO STARTED THE WAR(36) -
HE NEVER SAW IT COMING. HE HEARD IT.(36)
Alt text (accessibility, for the key frame): A small blind capuchin monkey with two eye patches stands at the crest of a hill, facing away from an enormous ring-shaped spacecraft in the sky behind him. The children around him are kneeling and looking up. His ears are raised.
APPENDIX — convergence with the other treatment
Outside the engines, and reported as an aside rather than a finding, because the brief was one document. It is here because it is the most useful thing in the folder.
The sibling treatment at G:\AVALON\New-Avalon\David\M2A Trailer.md tells a
different part of the same world — a generation ship, children taken one at a time,
an underworld beneath a false paradise. That is Floyd’s NOTES 3 through 6, dramatized.
Between them the two documents cover the property’s two halves: Floyd has the earth
side, David has the ship.
They converge, independently, on one image: children as counted inventory.
Floyd opens on “five hundred, eighty-two animals in all” and ends, in the notes, on a
cargo hold of cages. David opens on a HUD reading ABOARD: 4,998 and peaks on
ACQUISITION PROTOCOL — 71% COMPLETE. Neither writer needed the other to get there.
When two writers working separately land on the same image, that image is the property’s spine, not a coincidence. The count is the franchise. Whatever gets built next should be built on it.
Story Sherpa — Insight Extraction Engine, StoryBrand 7-Question brief, 4 Words /
5 Lines (full edition), Story Analyzer Rubric (8 outputs). Run 2026-09-04 on
G:\AVALON\New-Avalon\Floyd\Mission to Avalon Trailer-2026.md.