# Sep 24, 18:44

*A phone conversation between Chipp and Floyd. Chipp recorded it on his Rabbit R1.*

## Video scribing and visual metaphor

### What makes a scribe work

**Floyd:** People never understand that you're dealing in a more basic kind of thing, some place between cable, pictures on a cable.

**Chipp:** Floyd, what specifically? Are you talking about the scribe, or the scribe form done well? A whiteboard scribe?

**Floyd:** It could be scribe, but it doesn't have to be whiteboard. It's not just illustrating. It's illustrating, but it's also metaphoring everything. When you see something like that, it kind of takes my breath away, because I realize: there it is.

### Test case: the parable of the lost sheep

**Chipp:** So if you had something you were trying to describe, like a Bible parable, how would you write a prompt for it? Give me an example of a single parable. Just tell me one you already know, so we have something to talk about.

**Floyd:** I haven't thought about that very much, so I'm probably not capable. I would typically break a parable down into a recognizable, describable chunk. Take a lot being found. If you can think of a little squiggly sheep sauntering around like a baby Bigfoot lost in the woods, and being found. The parable of the lost sheep.

**Chipp:** Oh, okay. I didn't know that one.

**Floyd:** It's always been part of the Christography, of the words he told. But beyond that, being lost versus being found is at the very heart of it, and that's the part of the metaphor that gets lost when it's done in a lousy way.

**Chipp:** What is the story? If you had to break it down to beginning, middle and end, or more than that?

**Floyd:** Basically, the story comes down to the value of a human. That's the interpretation. Hold that in the background.

Christ told this parable: there's a farmer who has a hundred sheep, and he counts them every night as he's putting them up. It's part of the finishing of the day and the final security of the day. He realizes that one sheep is lost. He's not going to pen up the rest and abandon that lost sheep. He's going to go out and find it. It's much better told than I've just told it. It's concise and very powerful.

The point is, he's not satisfied that *only* one is missing. He's *dissatisfied* that one is missing. You can see the distinction. What you want to see is the value of that one individual, as opposed to the entire flock, which is the aggregate sum of his wealth. He goes out to look for it and puts an extraordinary amount of effort into reclaiming that lost sheep. That's the way Christ metaphored himself: he's out to reclaim the lost sheep of Israel.

**Chipp:** And at the end?

**Floyd:** At the end, he finds the sheep and brings it in.

It was powerful in the language of Israel at that period of history, because Israel was feeling lost in the battle with the Roman Empire. It had lost its identity, and there were people getting all sorts of crazy magical weirdness going on. Christ was repeating a theme that was very poignant to the people at the time, who understood the bounds of that miracle. That's why it's almost mystical when you talk about it in those terms. You have to find and express something big enough for a person in the culture to understand. You can do a lot of magical comparisons and metaphors. In this day and age, people don't understand the connective tissue. They don't even know history, so you're restricted to bare bones, because they'd have to read history.

**Chipp:** So the parable is itself a metaphor?

**Floyd:** It's a metaphor for the love of Christ.

**Chipp:** But the parable is a literal metaphor, right? Meaning, if you drew it in a video scribe, you'd draw sheep and a guy running a flock.

**Floyd:** If you Google it, you'll inevitably find a picture of a man dressed in long robes, with a sheep over his shoulder, carrying it back. It's the regard for that one sheep, without disregarding the 99 that are safely penned, that took that man back out into the night to find out where the poor little thing was. When you look at the metaphor in its simplest terms, in graphic arts and Christian literature, you'll almost always see Jesus carrying a sheep over his shoulder. He never did that, by the way.

### Sketching the scenes

**Chipp:** I get that, but I'm back to creating this video scribe and thinking about what you just said. Scene one would show a guy with a bunch of sheep, herding them somewhere, on a hill or something.

**Floyd:** There's probably a distinction to be made here, at least in my mind, but it's not worth breaking into. Yes, you could start with a sheep herder. You might indicate counting, but I don't know how you'd do that. You want a clean stylizing of information, but counting is a big part of it. He finds that somehow there's a missing sheep, and that's best told by word. How do you show "I'm missing one"?

**Chipp:** Maybe you have a hundred sheep, then a little flip-card sign that only says 99, with a big question mark coming out of him. I'm just trying to think.

**Floyd:** You're right. A little counter going: 97, 98, 99. Then, if you're telling more of an animated story, you'd see the night, the turbulence of darkness, and the possibility of eyes in the dark.

**Chipp:** Like wolves in the dark.

**Floyd:** Just two little bright yellow eyes, to scare the jeepers out of you. Then at the end you see the guy coming back in from the darkness with a little sheep over his shoulder. That's a full story without a lot of words in it. It wouldn't be necessary to say "and Jesus found his flock," or "and Israel was saved." None of that.

### Two narrative streams

**Floyd:** That's an excellent point, because in filmic language you don't have to use language to restate what's being shown. This is where viewer completion is so vital. Honestly, if you have someone actually saying it, it defrauds the merit a little.

**Chipp:** But video scribes all have narration. So how do you not do that?

**Floyd:** The narration is always going some other place. In my best-case scenario, if my adult mind is awake enough to figure it out, I'd be telling another story: the worth of an individual. The narration directed to the viewer would talk about how we live in a world with a lot of other important goals. Very often we lose our identity, and maybe even our sense of purpose and value in the world. A loss of value, to the people you love and the people who live around you, is probably the greatest loss of all.

Take what I just said, imagine it better spoken, and play it in front of this abstracted parable of the lost sheep. You've got two lines of language running together, but not defining each other. You're not saying the word "sheep" while a little fuzzy white thing pops up in the field. There are two narrative streams running.

**Chipp:** I see exactly what you're saying. The narration doesn't talk about a sheep herder, a herd of sheep or wolf eyes.

### Example: the Germany hammer

**Floyd:** The best thing a scribe ever did was that piece I did for the scribe thing. I was talking about Germany and its incredibly insane buildup after World War I, getting ready for World War II, and all that was going on. I showed a picture of a hammer with the word "Germany" on it, and a nail ready to go into a board, just floating there in the nimbus. Then, as the story says Germany hit Poland in 1939, the hammer crashes down on the nail and drives it through the little board.

In other words, there's a distance between the visual analogy and the story being told, and that's what makes it powerful. If you decipher all the best things you've seen, and you've seen more than I have, you'll find this funny little linkage by inference between what's happening on screen and what's being said. That inference is where viewer completion happens. It's a gap. It's a pregnant, knowing gap.

## Chipp's offline recorder on the Rabbit R1

### Why he built it

**Chipp:** Let me change the subject and tell you what I've been working on, because it's pretty fascinating. It's not this, though eventually I like the idea of using the scribing tool for this.

Do you remember the Rabbit R1?

**Floyd:** I played with it. I actually took notes with it, all sorts of things. It's kind of falling out of use. Right now it's still sitting by my computer.

**Chipp:** You don't have a Windows machine nearby, do you? You have a Mac. Okay.

I've had great conversations with you forever, and I've been having some great ones with David, and some good ones with Lloyd. I always think these would be great little podcasts, because there's so much interesting stuff said and the conversation flows. I watch a lot of podcasts on TV and they're boring. I have more interesting conversations with my friends than these people are having about interesting stuff. At least I think so.

### How he built it

I first started with a little device called an ESP32. I tried to write firmware to make it an offline audio recorder, and it didn't work. It didn't have enough memory, and it would only give me 20 or 30 minutes, which isn't enough.

Then I thought: wait a minute, I have this old Rabbit sitting in a drawer somewhere. I went searching, found it, pulled it out and started querying Grok: can I make this thing into an audio recorder that's offline, works, and has noise suppression and gap suppression, so if it's quiet it doesn't record anything?

So I set it up. You have to wipe out the Rabbit OS and install Android on it.

### What it does

I'm recording right now as we talk. Everything you and I have been talking about, I'm recording. But it's offline:

- It's not connected to the internet.
- It will never be in a cloud anywhere.
- There's no security headache.

It's amazing, and I have all these little features:

- I can turn audio noise suppression on or off.
- I can turn on "don't record gaps."
- I can connect it to the cloud, hit a button, and it'll upload the recording and transcribe it in three different ways that I want.
- It transcribes the whole thing, converts it three different ways into notes, and automatically makes a webpage. I have that working too.
- Any picture you take gets a timestamp automatically, so it can insert it in the right place in the transcription. The Magic Recorder does the same. If you're with your kids on Christmas recording everything, you can take pictures of your grandkids opening a present. Or at a basketball game, Connor making a shot, those kinds of things.

To install it, you have to hook the Rabbit up to a computer with a cable to wipe the firmware. I've got it all set up so it's done by AI, so if you have an AI account it'll work.

### Plans for this conversation

I'm going to take this conversation, have it transcribed, then break it out into separate conversations, especially the one about the parable, because I want to use that parable as a test for the scribe tool I want to build.

If it's good enough, I want to take your voice and use it as the person talking, with your cadence. That's a completely different cadence than when you read stuff. It's more exciting to me. Same with my voice: in my videos, my voice has that reading cadence, where I'm saying it a different way. But the conversations you and I have carry an energy that reading doesn't.

**Floyd:** I understand.

**Chipp:** I'm really so excited.

### Rabbit's Magic Recorder

**Chipp:** We should get your Rabbit out, if you still have it.

**Floyd:** I actually had a dialogue with Rabbit at the beginning, because I was trying to find the best way to use it as a transcriber. That was the very first thing I tried with it.

**Chipp:** We talked about this. I remember. If you upgrade your Rabbit to the latest version, it has something called Magic Recorder, which is pretty decent. It's not as good as what I'm doing, but it can finally record offline, which is nice, because that was always the problem: you lose Wi-Fi and boom, you're dead in the water. When you're back online, you hit a button and it transcribes in the cloud for you. Or you can use my product. Either way.

**Floyd:** It's a very interesting product and a very interesting idea.

## Floyd on fluency, patterns and memory

**Floyd:** If I can be personally honest with you, I have a sadness about my own fluency, my own logical ordering.

**Chipp:** That's the whole point of this. You talk, and it transcribes it and orders it for you.

**Floyd:** I get that. But I've been talking about this: I'm having to go by patterns. If you're blind in the dark, you reach out and feel for edges, and you make your way through the room by touch, or by the feeling that you bumped into the grandfather clock. I'm kind of at that point right now. Honestly, Chipp, there were certain processes of deciphering I used when I was trying to figure out a lot of things in animation and a lot of programming. I'm not a programmer, but I learned a lot through blunt-headed, bull-moose charging into it, and figured out trails and patterns. Now I almost exclusively have to know what the pattern is, or I can't move.

**Chipp:** I don't think you're covering brand-new ground. How many times do I go into the kitchen and can't remember what I went in for, then go back to my bedroom, remember it, go back to the kitchen and forget again? I have such lapses, not only in short-term memory but in basic analytical skills. I don't say it too loud, because I feel like I'm cursed.

**Floyd:** That's exactly what I'm talking about.

**Chipp:** So having a little device I can record stuff on helps.

## Family news

### Floyd's granddaughter, prom queen

**Floyd:** That reminds me of something I need to tell you. Today my granddaughter was queen of the prom in her senior class. It's really kind of incredible. They voted her in. I couldn't go, because my meds make me unreliable as an audience member, but I got a message from Nancy saying she was just beautiful. I got that news about an hour ago, and I'm really excited. Nancy went to the ceremony. All I did was sit around, wash dishes and think about my granddaughter.

**Chipp:** Is she going to be trouble for some guy?

**Floyd:** She's actually found a wonderful guy. He seems to be the sweetest guy. I've got to make sure I give him a stamp of approval.

**Chipp:** Well, you need to meet him.

**Floyd:** I've met him.

**Chipp:** Here's what I'd suggest. Just take a bullet out and toss it to him. Let him catch it in the air, then say, "Listen, if you don't treat her right, the next one's coming a little faster."

**Floyd:** That is so funny.

**Chipp:** Who was the king?

**Floyd:** Alnberg, the guy she's dating. He's a big soccer player. Well, not big. He's about six foot tall, probably, but he's captain of the soccer team.

### Private versus public school

**Chipp:** Do they go to a private or public school?

**Floyd:** A private school. It's Christian. It's not as doctrinaire in some sense of the word, but at its basis it leans toward the Protestant side, as opposed to a Catholic school.

**Chipp:** If you'd talked to me 30 years ago, I'd have said you've got to go to public school, because you've got to get all that. Now I'm like, no, you want to be protected from the world as long as possible. Public school is freaking dangerous. It's dangerous to your health.

**Floyd:** It was bad enough when we were in high school. You know what that's like.

**Chipp:** I know what public school was like. I went to a way worse one than you did. I went to a couple of pretty bad schools. The second one, in Missouri, was a lot better. But my high school in Fort Worth was about as rowdy, rough and murderous as it gets. So I've got a big picture on that.

**Floyd:** I've probably told you this, but I had a huge argument with my brother about private versus public schools. I paid a fortune to put Casey through the best private school in the Tarrant County area, Fort Worth. My brother said, "You're raising a hothouse plant. Don't you understand he needs to face the real world?" I said, "I lived in the real world. I know your argument."

**Chipp:** I was like your brother.

**Floyd:** But guess what: he enrolled both of his own sons in the same private school. I'm a hundred percent believer. He was so dismayed that I was growing a hothouse child, but I got a kid who punched through his master's degree. I don't think he'll ever get his PhD. He's been out too long at this point to go back for his doctorate. He's a great kid.

**Chipp:** I feel kind of the same way about Ivy League schools. I hate their curriculum, and I hate their leftist leanings. But if your kid goes to an Ivy League school, there's a really good chance he'll network with the right people, so when he gets out in the real world he has plenty of opportunities to choose from.

**Floyd:** You're right.

**Chipp:** And kids are already baked by the time they go to college. College doesn't bake kids. They're already who they're going to be in life. They're not going to become somebody completely different because some stupid liberal college professor gets hold of one and tells them to hate Jews or whatever. That's not who they are.

**Floyd:** Well, the fact that they didn't die from the long end of the world, that's basically what I was voting for. That's exactly what I thought about.

I'm very proud of my little bug. She was my post-marriage special project.

## Chipp's day with David tomorrow

**Chipp:** I've got all day tomorrow with David Avalid. I've still been working on my workflow. I started working with Tape 2 of Avalon, and that got to be too much for me, so I backed it down to another story, and then that got to be too much too. At some point it gets tedious, and I don't want it to be. My goal is to figure out how to make it not tedious. It is tedious work, and I don't want to do tedious work.

So I'm going to sit down with David, because David knows how to create videos in a day, little advertising pieces. I didn't know that, but he does it for IBM, and I'm like, oh crap, are you kidding me? So I asked if I could come over to his house and spend a day with him. I just want to watch him do it and learn. I'm taking my little recorder. I'm going to own that process, so once I see the right process, I can figure out where to put the shortcuts in.

## About David

### Floyd's view of David

**Floyd:** Of all the people I ever worked with, he's probably the most gifted.

**Chipp:** There have been a lot of gifted people around you, that's for sure.

**Floyd:** He was gifted in a way that was different. It could be that his religious heritage was similar to mine, and we tend to talk the same language as a result. When I moved up here, he actually helped me write some commands.

**Chipp:** He was talking about motion books the other day. He said, "I wonder if Floyd could see motion books." I told him he'd never seen *Raising the Dead*, and I told him the story about how you came up with this whole avatar thing back in the seventies or eighties. It's crazy. It's been around forever in your mind. And you wrote a book. He said, "Oh, I need to get that book from Floyd." You should send me a PDF of it, because it's a fantastic book. It's fascinating, and to think it was created back in the day, before any of this stuff, when it was all science fiction.

**Floyd:** I've got it up on YouTube. The entire audiobook version is on YouTube.

**Chipp:** I'll tell him. That's wonderful. He's a good guy.

**Floyd:** He's great. I can't talk to either you or him before 1 or 1:30 PM on Sunday, because you guys are locked in.

### David's family

**Floyd:** He may not remember it, because it was only a brief encounter, but I met his mom and dad.

**Chipp:** I'm sure he remembers it.

*(The call broke up briefly here.)*

**Floyd:** His mom and dad are simply wonderful, and a lot of my understanding of him comes from what I saw there. He grew up in a very special place where his creativity was encouraged. He had a lot of spiritual values. Talk about being baked in: they were baked in very deep.

I knew a lot of people in the Hispanic community in Austin. A lot of them were old-time, from the old Mexican blood in the area, and they all knew who his dad was.

**Chipp:** His dad was an incredible basketball player.

**Floyd:** Some of the people I knew didn't even know David or anybody else. They said, "Oh yeah, he's the preacher. He plays basketball. You should see him play ball." So his dad had a reputation as a minister, but also, in the Hispanic community, as an incredible ball player.

**Chipp:** That's so cool. David came out and played with me a couple of times at the Hills.

David just moved into a new place. He kept his old house and moved into a duplex right in the middle of town. I went and saw it, and it's real nice. His wife, Victoria, is sweet. I like her too. The other day we went to lunch, and he pointed out a condo nearby and said it's about $280,000, and he's going to buy it for his parents or something like that. So his parents are still around.

**Floyd:** That's good. They're just wonderful.

**Chipp:** The Avalids have been there six generations or something. He said his family is responsible for bringing fayette [fajita] meat to Texas. Anytime he's out eating it, he says, "Yeah, you're welcome." He's so funny.

**Floyd:** I go back to what I said about all these Tejanos I knew. I had a wonderful Tejano, Rudy Rodriguez, who cut my hair for years. Rudy was totally alien to church, just a good old Mexicano. When I told him about David, I wondered if he knew the family. He knew the Avalids, and it seemed the Avalids were like founders.

**Chipp:** They've been around forever, and there's a million of them. And David is so kind to his cousin, Eric. He has saved that boy's life over and over again. It's stunning what he does for him. That's why I admire him so much. I deeply admire him.

## Memories of making Avalon

**Floyd:** I admired him when he was shepherding Eric while we were doing Avalon. Eric had a lot of opinions about how anime should look.

**Chipp:** And of course we had a whole chicken house filled with anime freaks, didn't we? Roosting on every tree in the yard. And then Human Code Japan jumping in with their take on everything. Remember that?

**Floyd:** I'm not sure we would ever have come to any kind of completion of the effort, because there was so much current in the water. It could have swirled in 50 directions.

**Chipp:** You're so correct. It was funny, though. It's wonderful to remember that. It was a wonderful period.

**Floyd:** It would have been nice if we'd got the 13 episodes.

**Chipp:** Yeah, that would have been nice.

## Chipp's health

**Floyd:** My wife's trying to get me to do something I can't do. I've only got two hands, and my feet don't work well.

**Chipp:** My feet either. I was pretty sick this week. I had a fever of 103. Can you believe that?

**Floyd:** Oh, Chipp, what is it?

**Chipp:** I don't know. I wasn't feeling good, but I went out to San Marcos and walked around so much in the hot 110-degree sun, and my feet just can't take that. But it was a chance to be with Mercedes. We walked around and shopped for her and for Christy, and had the best time. I don't care how bad my feet hurt. You've been there. It's just fun to be with those you love.

Man, I was so sick the next day, and then for two days I ran a fever and felt crappy. I haven't been able to sleep. It's nuts. But I'm feeling better. I knew I had Friday coming up, so I had to get better for that. I'm so looking forward to tomorrow, being with David and doing this stuff.

**Floyd:** I'm excited for it. You'll have to give me a bullet list of what you talked about.

## Homework for Floyd: try the Magic Recorder

**Chipp:** Here's your homework. Get out your Rabbit, download the latest version of the OS, try the Magic Recorder, and tell me what you think of it. If you're looking for a memory tool, that's not a bad one.

**Floyd:** I'll give it a shot. I've tried to use it in my own different ways. I think I told you: I actually wrote to Rabbit telling them they needed a killer app, and that they needed to have writers.

**Chipp:** That is the killer app. You're right.

Just so you know:

- A triple click on the little power button on the right automatically goes into Magic Recorder mode.
- You don't have to scroll through and tap things. If you want to instantly start recording a note, you can.
- It might turn out to be something you do a lot.
- You can record conversations with your doctors. They may not let you in person, but on the phone they don't care. If they want to give you instructions, you can say, "Hold on," and triple click.

**Floyd:** I'm going to see my blood doctor next week.

**Chipp:** You sound good. Are you feeling better?

**Floyd:** I am feeling better. There's evidence I'm still leaking blood, I don't know where. But there's also evidence about my anemia: I don't have it as bad. When I'm anemic, my head just goes sideways and I'm not good for anything. It's a fight, but I'm happy, and my little bug is making me right proud, as they say.

## The group chat and Mission to Avalon

**Chipp:** I got a group text from Gary, Lloyd and David Palumbo, and one other person. Me, I think. That's probably the four of us. I told them I'm working on Mission to Avalon with your script and all that, and they all wished me the best. So I'm still committed to doing it.

**Floyd:** Don't break your head. There's a lot you might discover on the trail to Avalon that's more important to discover. Avalon was a lot of discoveries.

## Beyond the video scribe

**Floyd:** The more important takeaway is whether it provokes a direction for you to take. What you're talking about is, as far as I'm concerned, as grand as it gets. You're talking about a new way to use what we'll call the alphabetic qualities of language, because it's not just an alphabet. There's more to it. You're knocking on the big mystery.

**Chipp:** I think you're right. We humans have figured out what video scribing is, and you and I fell in love with scribing years and years ago. What's the one after that? What's between a video scribe and a feature film? What does that look like?

**Floyd:** I don't want to pretend I know at all.

**Chipp:** I can visualize some stuff that might be interesting, but I would love to be part of inventing that new language. Maybe Avalon is a way to tell that story. I don't know. Maybe not try to mimic what has been done, but instead create what can be done.

### Floyd's two states

**Floyd:** I can't fully describe it, but there are two states I think are vital, and between them are probably the variables for the most that language can do:

1. Tell a story.
2. Carry powerful emotions with it, and be visualized in a cooperative sense. We're only looking to see a finished frame.

So we're telling two stories. One of the interesting things about movies is that the best films never tell you what they're telling you in the story. They never haul off and say, "This stands for a shepherd, and this is a sheep." At that level of story, the inference is something you should be supplying as the listener, not something you're being told. In screenwriters' circles, the complaint is that you're describing with words what you should be describing with visuals. The visuals should carry it, and the fewer words you have to say, the better. It's like making an argument for silent films.

When you learn to read a scribe where there's a lot of what we'll call sub-visual metaphor going on, you're hearing the theme, the skeleton, but you also have this visual reinforcement, reinforcing a certain kind of pattern in every way you can. That's the amazing part, because you're in a zone people haven't explored. They simply didn't have a typewriter that would give them a scribe, with the subtlety of visual language and visual metaphor. This is the only time this could be invented, as a language, right now.

If you look at the C.S. Lewis doodles and watch them, you'll see this magic lurking just outside the frame, leaking into the frame occasionally. That magic is what we're talking about.

### Jurassic Park and RSA Animate

**Chipp:** Remember in *Jurassic Park*, where they had that little animation? The same kind of magic?

**Floyd:** The same magic in the sense that, at a very blunt level, it gives you visual reinforcement for what it's saying. They're still somewhat duplicating, but it's different. If you analyze it, in my mind there's a difference in quality between *Jurassic Park*'s revelation and a lot of what passes for video scribing. *Jurassic Park* did a very good job.

**Chipp:** I think the best was RSA, the Royal Society thing, the RSA Animate people. They had it dialed in pretty good.

**Floyd:** And it began with good writing. The words you speak are not what matter. The words you don't speak, amplified and paved over by visual metaphor: that's a better road to travel.

## Wrapping up

**Chipp:** Do me a favor and get your Rabbit out. Update the software, see if it works for you, and see if you can sit there and just ramble to yourself for a while. Feed it into the Rabbit AI, it'll organize it for you, and then play it back.

**Floyd:** I can only do that with friends who want to get off the phone. I can ramble like that forever, but I have to have a friend on the phone. So I'll just call you.

**Chipp:** You can call me and ramble away. Absolutely.

**Floyd:** Tell David hi for me.

**Chipp:** I've got a 43-minute recording going right now, so I'll talk to you later.

**Floyd:** Okay, buddy. Thank you. Bye.
