← all render tests

Concept Magic - website hero placeholders (cloud round: Midjourney + ChatGPT)

Round 2, cloud engines only (Midjourney + ChatGPT/GPT Image), same 3 concepts as the local round. VERDICT: ChatGPT won decisively on brand fidelity. Its c1 drone and c2 rover both render the clay-to-finished seam that was the actual brief, on a true charcoal ground with a quiet left third for the headline; its c3 cube is a flat matte orange wireframe on charcoal with construction lines and one teal node - the closest thing either round has produced to BRAND.md section 5. Midjourney imposed its house aesthetic despite --style raw --s 50: c1 lost the seam entirely (read it as a stripe on the background wall) and used teal as a decorative body panel; c2 came back as a glowing sci-fi rover, the exact gaming/cyberpunk look the brand doc tells us to avoid; c3 swapped the charcoal ground for warm brown paper and drew a solid filled cube instead of wireframe line-work. Kept in full for comparison, not hidden. EXPOSURE FLAGS: the ChatGPT c3 pair reads near-black to the photo-profile gate (mean 15-20). That is by design - it is a background plate on the brand ground #0E1013 - so the flag is the wrong lens, not a defect. Judge it by eye. ChatGPT c2 has three renders because a WebDAV write lag made one look missing; the re-render is a bonus seed, all three kept.
aspect 16:9 · 3 prompt(s) · 19 image(s) · Midjourney + ChatGPT (GPT Image)

Midjourney

Prompt 1

show prompt

Concept 1 - The transformation: gray untextured clay hard-surface model (drone/vehicle) splitting along one clean seam into a fully finished styled render; subject right of center, left third quiet charcoal for the headline; bright key light.

#1
#2
#3
#4

Prompt 2

show prompt

Concept 2 - The styled model: one finished hard-surface concept model on a charcoal seamless sweep, half clay-gray / half fully materialized, one orange-red rim light; subject right of center, left third quiet; open mid-tones.

★ #5
#6
#7
#8

Prompt 3

show prompt

Concept 3 - The cube motif: abstract brand background - isometric wireframe cube in flat matte orange-red line-work with construction lines and nodes on charcoal, faint grid, generous negative space; drafting-table precision, no glow. (Full per-engine prompts: prompts.md)

#9
#10
#11
#12

ChatGPT (GPT Image)

Prompt 1

show prompt

Concept 1 - The transformation: gray untextured clay hard-surface model (drone/vehicle) splitting along one clean seam into a fully finished styled render; subject right of center, left third quiet charcoal for the headline; bright key light.

#13
#14

Prompt 2

show prompt

Concept 2 - The styled model: one finished hard-surface concept model on a charcoal seamless sweep, half clay-gray / half fully materialized, one orange-red rim light; subject right of center, left third quiet; open mid-tones.

#15
#16
#17

Prompt 3

show prompt

Concept 3 - The cube motif: abstract brand background - isometric wireframe cube in flat matte orange-red line-work with construction lines and nodes on charcoal, faint grid, generous negative space; drafting-table precision, no glow. (Full per-engine prompts: prompts.md)

#18
#19