Nov 2, 14:03
A design consultation between Chipp and Mark about the branding, website and app of the Museum for a Rainy Day (and its sister site, Grow). Chipp is the designer giving feedback; Mark is the museum’s founder.
Opening and Logistics
Payment
Chipp: I got a copy of it. I saw you went through all the hassle of Patreon. I need to change that. I need to have people pay through PayPal, because Patreon is terrible to be with. One, they take a big chunk of money out of it. And they also hold the money, so I can’t get it for over a month. It kind of sucks. But anyway, no big deal. We’re good now.
The Review Document
Mark: I sent you a URL in the chat. I’ve got the Discord open so I can see anything inside. It’s the Museum for a Rainy Day website design review and redesign. Did you see that?
Chipp: I just skimmed it. You just sent it.
Mark: I know, you haven’t looked at it yet. I’ve gone through it, not in great detail, but I need you to go through it in detail to make sure I’m not missing anything. It’s an AI-generated document, but I asked for some specific things and had it go back and fix some things I noticed right away that need to be right. In particular the top part: the executive summary, the customer value proposition, and that first at-a-glance section. That’s the part I’m interested in.
Session Records and Questions
Chipp: The website I created for you, the little site: after each meeting I’ll put a synopsis up there. It’ll just be a record of what we do. I’ll also put up questions for you to answer at the same place. It’s a simple webpage with a bunch of fields and buttons. There’s a little button in the top right-hand corner that I think says “Copy JSON.” Click on that button and send me whatever you’ve copied. Just Discord it to me, and I can feed it into my system.
Small Talk: Halloween in Spain
Chipp: Let me grab a drink real quick before we get started. Do you celebrate Halloween over there?
Mark: I’m actually in Spain right now. My wife is from Spain originally. She left on the 31st, on Halloween. We’re right near the ocean, so there’s a paseo where people walk by. I was watching, and there weren’t many kids out, so I guess there’s not that much Halloween here. It’s probably more in the port village itself. But I’m half American, so it’s part of my goal.
Mark’s Goals
For Working with Chipp
Chipp: Before we start, I’d like to understand your goals for this project. What are your expectations?
Mark: Specifically for working with you: I’m not a designer. I’ve acquired many skills over the years. I’d say I’m a generalist, master of none, except for the one thing I’m quite serious about, which is photography. I’m not a great graphic designer; any graphic design I’ve done was part of having to communicate things. I’m not a web designer either. Even in the early days of the Internet I learned HTML, but that doesn’t make me any kind of designer.
But I do have an eye for things, and I understand the importance of a cohesive design language and cohesive communication. That’s why I wanted to send you the screenshots and the MetaHuman material. Ideally, with your expertise — and if you can’t do it all, together with me, and if we need to bring in other people I’m happy to look at that too — I want to develop what used to be called a corporate identity, or here a museum identity, and a design language, so that whether people are using the app or the website, it all feels like one. I want it to feel professional. That’s important to me.
For the Museum
Mark: I think the story is told on the website. Over the years family members and friends have asked me when I’m going to do an exhibit, because they’ve seen some of my photography. I don’t really post it online, because I don’t want to feed Instagram and AI with my photos. Not that I’m overly protective, but there’s something different about people seeing it in a museum or gallery context. So for myself, I’d like something like the Museum for a Rainy Day to exist so people can enjoy my work. If that’s all it accomplishes, that’s the low-hanging fruit.
Extending that further, there are other artists I’ve become aware of over the years whom I see being extremely diligent in their practice. One of my favorite examples is Todd Kohnstein — I might have mentioned her last time. She has a very narrow house, three stories tall, and her entire house is full of her paintings. I’ve known her for something approaching 20 years and I’ve seen her art evolve. I think it’s really sad that unless you happened to be in Berlin during one of the five or six times she showed her paintings — I don’t even think it was a gallery, it was some café — you would never be able to see her art.
So I spent a lot of time and effort running the math and applying everything I’ve learned about building cloud services and infrastructure, figuring out how I can help myself and possibly, let’s say, 1,200 artists at a minimum have their own permanent exhibition across as many digital devices as possible. Depending on the device, it will always be a little different. The best experience, of course, is on a Meta Quest or a Vision Pro, but it should still be a decent experience on an iPad or an iPhone. Those are the baseline goals.
If I think really big, I’d like the Museum for a Rainy Day to be a serious museum that also showcases 3D artists in the future. When I think back to my early days with Blender and seeing things like the competitions, there’s so much amazing 3D talent. When I look at artists’ portfolios on ArtStation, there are so many people building gaming assets who are obviously serious, amazing artists. But for many of them there isn’t any outlet like the Museum for a Rainy Day where they can submit work and have it seen. So I would like to build a very serious digital museum, and for it to be cool and fun. That’s the goal for the museum.
Revenue and Grow
Mark: Revenue is secondary for me right now, because I’ve designed it properly and I have very low costs. But at some point I’d like to do special exhibits. I’m in conversation with a very serious curator of contemporary Chinese art. He’s currently still working at the Confucius Institute in Nuremberg. Before that he worked at Sotheby’s as a Chinese art dealer. He has a degree in art, and he’s been telling me about some of the challenges he has.
So in Grow, the sister site of the Museum for a Rainy Day, I want to start building tools for curators and artists — some free, some paid — to have a source of revenue there and expand that part of the business. I want to build a platform where people can come in, propose work and have it reviewed. Ideally much of that goes to the Museum for a Rainy Day, but it may also go to other digital museums, or simply be a good system for people to showcase and share their work for deployment in the appropriate museum. That’s a very condensed version of everything.
Chipp’s Summary
Chipp: So my understanding is that you want help with your branding and with the design of the website itself. You’ve identified that your customers are not only visitors to your site but also a variety of artists, whether 3D or traditional.
Mark: Traditional, or just for me — photography.
Brand: Logo
Chipp’s Critique
Chipp: Let’s begin with brand. Let me tell you what I think about your logo, and I’ll be brutal. I’m going to be honest with you.
Mark: I’m half German. I love it.
Chipp: The logo is pixelated. That communicates a lot of different things to me. It could be very youth-oriented. It could be game-oriented — pixelated stuff. It’s stylized. It can also have a rave feel; the younger generation, the rave scene, used fonts like that. It’s not [the font I was thinking of] — that one is all caps — but it’s something similar.
One more thing: there’s no color in it other than the four green dots, which actually looks kind of like a mistake. If you’re going to add color, you need to add it in a way people will notice. I know you want to explain why it is that way, but I don’t really care, because as a user you don’t get a chance to explain your logo to me — especially since Museum for a Rainy Day is not a brand anyone recognizes anywhere they go.
The good part is that “Museum for a Rainy Day” communicates what it is — not exactly, but close enough, and it makes you wonder what it means. I like the name a lot. That part of the brand I like.
You have something called a logo mark and a logotype. The logotype is the “Museum for a Rainy Day” part, the pixelated typography. The logo mark is the umbrella with the little green raindrops hitting it. I think that can work. I’m not sure it’s the right logo as designed, but it can definitely work for what you want to do. I would suggest considering changing it, but that’s up to you. If we want to stick with it, of course we can.
Mark’s Response
Mark: I did trademark applications and all that, and I realize that’s not a good reason to keep it. But to your point about what it brings to mind: the reason I like it is that we’re actually using gaming technology to visualize, so I thought it was applicable. To me it instantly communicates that this is something digital. When people hear “a museum for a rainy day,” they might not understand it’s a digital museum. Also, when I designed the logo I frankly didn’t want to get too caught up in it. I wanted to put something out there.
I’m in partial agreement with you. It’s probably not perfect, and I think the logotype is something that can evolve later. I’m much more concerned with where your criticism from the previous session was spot on.
What I meant about being German and criticism: growing up, I was always surprised to hear that German companies teach things like brainstorming. Why do you need a course on brainstorming? That’s just something Americans do. In my opinion, Germans are the ultimate critics. So rough criticism, as long as it’s constructive, is always appreciated. That’s how I work at my existing company too, and people have gotten used to it, even if they’re not German. So don’t worry about that.
What really resonated was when you said it’s pretty obvious no designer ever touched this website. So if I could focus your energy less on the logo and logotype and more on a consistent, cohesive design language, I’d prefer to prioritize that. Perhaps later we can do logo refinements.
The Logo at Small Sizes
Chipp: I want to share this picture with you.
Mark: You can share your screen — there’s a button down there. In the messaging you can’t share. You can put it in Dropbox, or just Discord.
Chipp: Here is Photoshop. At the top is the logo as it looks small, the way you’d use it in the corner of a website. At 72 DPI there just isn’t enough resolution for a logo that complex. What we can do is take the logo mark, use that, and put “Museum for a Rainy Day” next to it. We might be able to stretch it out next to it.
Mark: Maybe the problem is more what we’re trying to do with it. That font and that logo are fine when they’re big, fat and on screen. If it’s a title card and really large, I find it looks pretty cool. But the design pass I made shrank it too small. I was more focused on quickly incorporating your feedback and building something more flexible. Let me show you: this is just the umbrella on its own at 512 by 512, which is what we use for an icon, for example. Even when it’s small I think it’s okay. It’s not amazing.
Chipp: Do me a favor and send me the font you used for that. There are also kerning issues — serious kerning issues in “for a Rainy Day.” Keep in mind you’re trying to attract artists, people with aesthetic sensibilities. The logo is the very first thing they’ll see on your website, in the top left. I’m happy to try to do something with it. I’ll do my best, spend some time on it, and I’ll also suggest some other ideas. Just FYI.
Decision: The Umbrella as the Logo
Mark: Can I make one suggestion? On how the logo and the type work together, I completely agree with your criticism. Again, I wasn’t focused on that; I was simply trying to improve the website quickly to incorporate some of your feedback. I don’t think it needs the logotype at all. We could work entirely with the umbrella as the logo, and everything else can be regular type.
Chipp: Good, I like that. So we’ll take the umbrella. Let’s talk about the umbrella for a second. I’d like to add another green dot on the far right.
Mark: And I’m already crying, because it’s going to cost me something like $1,500 to add another variation with a new dot.
Trademarks
Chipp: Hold on before you do that. I’ve owned tons of companies, I’ve done tons of logos for people, I’ve done a lot of branding. Why are you trademarking it? I’m trying to understand the point.
Mark: Because I want to do t-shirts and tote bags — I want some kind of museum gift shop. Also — I don’t know if I mentioned this last time — I’m talking with a Chinese manufacturer about possibly selling logo cases and similar items, and bundling apps with them. That’s where I’m a bit concerned.
Chipp: I think your money isn’t well spent there. Of the companies I’ve owned, the only time I ever trademarked the logo was when investors came in and gave me millions of dollars for the company. They demanded the trademark to protect their money. Other than that I’ve never trademarked anything. I think you can put a TM on something without registering a trademark — I’d look into that. As I recall, back in the day I could put a TM on something and it was legal, and it was a way of protecting it. More importantly, if you have the image on your website or somewhere public with a date by it, that’s a way of protecting your property as well. You’re welcome to spend the money; I’m just letting you know.
Mark: That money is already spent. I don’t want to fall for the sunk cost fallacy here. That’s why I’m perfectly open to you changing the logo however you want.
Chipp: We’ll keep the pixelated look. Maybe there are other areas where we can work, where there can be an evolution. Can we fix ten other things and then slowly but surely sweep back to it? We’ll use the umbrella as it is, but I’ll add a little dot. I might add some color to it, just FYI. But we do need a version of it that reads in black and white, because sometimes you’ll need that.
Mark: I have a black and white version. The umbrella works well on both white and black. I just dropped into Discord what it looks like in black and white. Do you use Affinity Designer?
Chipp: Yeah.
Mark: Let me drop you a postcard design as well, which has it in black and white.
Fonts and Vector Files
Chipp: Send me that font, by the way, when you get a chance.
Mark: I’m hunting for it on the drive while we talk. For much of the signage in the museum we use D-DIN, which is an open source font, but that’s not the logo font. I’ll send you D-DIN, which we use for signage, plus the actual logo font, and the vectors — whatever the latest version is. I had to recreate the logo at one point because I’d done a rough version and hadn’t saved the file properly. A friend of mine who’s a graphic designer helped me recreate it. She actually had to redraw it, because the logo was so pixelated in places from feathering and so on. So there’s no perfect version.
I did license the logo font. It’s driving me crazy that I can’t find it. It looks like here it was already converted. I’ll figure it out, and I’ll send you a bunch of the assets we’re using.
D-DIN wasn’t my first choice, but I picked it because it’s an open source font and it was similar to another one I’d found. I can drop that one to you right away.
Oh, here’s the other font — I found it. It’s weird: I looked through my archive for the font before and couldn’t find it, and now while looking for the other one I find it. This is the stylized font that’s only used in the logo. And the other one is in my git repo — one advantage of open source fonts is you can put them in a repo. I’ll zip that up. I dropped the two fonts in there.
Chipp: Got them. I see them right here.
Brand: Color, Look and Feel
The Current Palette
Chipp: Next I want to talk about your color palette. I don’t think it’s great. I think it’s British racing green, and it doesn’t do it for me — even though I had an MGB as a kid. It’s not even a forest green. British racing green is the closest color I can think of.
Mark: The colors I chose for that palette were about finding complementary colors that could break up the layouts a bit. In the latest revision of the website, which looks very different from before, look at the two artists who are represented there. If we had even more artists represented, I didn’t want it to go too far in the Windows-tile direction, but I need to break it up somehow. It needs to feel a bit more accessible.
Chipp’s Recommendation
Chipp: Using large regions of color isn’t going to work well, I don’t think, because it will overwhelm any art you put on the page. Do you know color theory — hue, saturation, value? Tertiary color themes, monochromatic color themes?
Mark: I do.
Chipp: I think we want to go with whites and grays, maybe some muted colors, but no big areas of bright colors, or colors in general that will fight whatever image you put there. Unless you’re not planning to put any art on the front page, which is fine too. You could go with a monochromatic, clean, modern, maybe playful interior — the logo is definitely playful — but with something very colorful and bright on the front that doesn’t change much. Or you only put images there that never change, or you find artists whose work actually fits the color theme you’re working with. You follow me?
Mark: I do.
Mood Board Assignment
Chipp: You started off on a mood board — you know what a mood board is? I thought you’d started by making screenshots of things you liked.
Mark: No. After you gave that feedback on the website, I did a brand new pass, and I was trying to break up the information a bit. I was working with Claude, I think, to come up with it.
Chipp: Sorry, I thought I saw that. Do you know how to create a mood board?
Mark: There’s stuff like PureRef.
Chipp: You can do that. Or you’ve basically done it here — you’ve got four different pictures in a single picture. Did you use Photoshop? You can do it with something like Google Slides: open a slide, drop a bunch of pictures in, and it’ll reformat them for you. I’d suggest going to Behance — I don’t use those sites anymore because I know what I want, but I think it’s Behance — and its gallery.
Mark: I actually want to build a mood board type app in Grow.
Chipp: You can do that, but I’d rather you spend your time — you can do whatever you want — finding websites. Just Google website design; there are a bunch of galleries out there now. Find places with websites, grab pictures — right-click, copy image, paste it in Discord. That’s fine. If you can collect some things you like, that would help me.
When I did this document for you, I said: evaluate this from a designer’s standpoint, from a marketing standpoint, from a gallery owner and curator’s standpoint, and from an artist’s standpoint. I wanted to look at it from a lot of different angles. I’m going to do the same here; I’ll generate some images too.
And if there’s stuff you really like — for instance, if you’d said you like British racing green because you had an MGB or have a sports car connection — or images of a particular camera you like, that helps. It doesn’t have to be something we’ll copy. We used to do something called semantic inquiry: if the company were an animal, what kind of animal would it be? If it were a food, what kind of food? If you wanted a famous actor, movie star or any celebrity to promote your website, who would it be? Those are valuable for letting me get inside your head, because what we don’t want is me going off and doing something I like and think is appropriate, but that doesn’t fit you. That’s the challenge.
You can also do the mood board by generating images in Midjourney or ChatGPT or whatever. I don’t care where it comes from. Let’s just try to come up with something we like and find interesting.
Mark’s Direction for the Look
Mark: In a nutshell: I’ve looked at traditional museum websites like the Tate and MoMA, and I’m not in love with them. At the same time I don’t want it to be too technology-driven. The nod to the technology side is that logotype. I’d like it to look sophisticated but not feel overly like a museum, because what we’re doing with the Museum for a Rainy Day isn’t a typical museum. Also, a lot of museum websites seem very institutional, and I’d like this to feel more accessible.
When we did the first iterations of the website, we had copy saying that it’s not about an artist’s subscriber count on one hand or their Instagram follower count. But on the flip side, it’s also not about how many paintings they’ve sold or how many exhibitions they’ve had. There’s a simple curation process. What we’re really trying to identify is a person who is regularly practicing in their chosen field of art, or design — I’m hoping for design as well — or photography.
If you’re talking about a product, I can’t really model it on a camera. I own a million cameras and I like cameras, but any of those would feel too technical. At the same time, it needs to be clear that it’s a digital museum. That’s what was hard.
Chipp: Let me make a note here.
Chipp’s Own Brand as an Example
Chipp: Do me a favor and go to chippwalters.com. In my case I’ve chosen a teal and a red-orange color, and a font I like. If you scroll down through the little tiles, they have abstract images — they’re not actually showing what Illustration Station, Concept or any of those products are. If you click over to desktop apps, you get the same kind of thing.
The point is that I’ve created a brand I can now use for anything. If you go to my Patreon page, that brand exists there. On my Superhive page, it exists there. On Gumroad, it exists there. All my YouTube thumbnails now have the same brand. It doesn’t always use the exact same look and feel, but it generates that continuity.
Mark: I remember your Patreon and your Gumroad didn’t used to look like that, so I recognize the effort and time you invested to deliver that continuity. I agree it doesn’t need to look the same everywhere. But it would bother me and make me sad if we didn’t find a way to have continuity between the experiences.
Chipp: That’s our overall goal with the brand: the logo, the color theme, and picking a typeface we like. The strongest design element known to mankind is color. You could take a Volkswagen, paint it Ferrari red, and it becomes something different. Colors are big, and typography is huge. You have a very distinctive font, though I don’t know if it’s the one we’ll end up with — it’s certainly not a font anyone can read text in.
Mark: It was never intended for that. That’s why I’ve been using D-DIN.
Mark’s Concern: Art Is Two-Dimensional for Now
Chipp: While we talk, I’ve got some skills on my computer here and I’m trying to generate images I think might be interesting — and having a hard time, believe it or not. I’ll paste a couple in, but I don’t like any of them. These are all really crappy; these are just terrible. But I’ll show you anyway. You can probably see the two that just popped up. I’m going to Midjourney. Have you used Midjourney?
Mark: I have, but only to test how well it could create fake photos.
Chipp: Midjourney is really good for concept work. Here’s the prompt; let’s try this.
Mark: I really like the “place for curiosity” look. I think that’s one reason I keep going back to black — though I don’t like black. The tricky thing is that I don’t have 3D images like that; I’m working primarily with two-dimensional images at this point. How do I make that work? I love anything with those robots — that’s awesome — but I don’t have a three-dimensional robot.
Chipp: I got that. At the start I’m focused on look and feel — color themes — more than headlines and typography. And if you think about that robot for a second, it could be a 3D picture frame with a picture in it. Do you follow me? It can be 3D, but it could also be a 3D picture frame with a 2D piece of art in it.
Mark: Just remember the fundamental challenge: for now, we mostly have two-dimensional art. Later we’ll have more flexibility when we actually have 3D art inside.
Chipp: Okay, then don’t give me feedback on these yet. Let me put together a mood board for you and suggest some things. That makes things go faster, because I’ll only show you things I like, so I don’t have to convince you why something is bad if you pick it.
Chipp: We haven’t gotten to the headline and the marketing component yet; that’s the next part. But let’s wrap this part up. You use AI a lot, right?
Mark: I do.
Chipp: ChatGPT isn’t bad for this kind of thing. ChatGPT is going to be the best, by the way, for all your marketing language — the marketing copy, all your headlines — but it’s also really good for fine-tuning the imagery. We’ll come up with some ideas and I’ll put together a website you can look at.
Tools Tangent
Chipp: I’ve almost completely finished Photoshop — I’ve done a clean-room redesign of Photoshop and added new free AI features that work with your existing ChatGPT subscription. This is cool. I’ve got another one: do you know Inkscape?
Mark: Yes, that’s a really old program. I might be confusing it with another one.
Chipp: It’s an open source Illustrator. It competes with Illustrator and has a lot of features Illustrator doesn’t have, which I like, and I like the way it works better. But it’s an old program and it shows its age. Since it’s completely open source, I’m completely rebuilding it, with all the path effects. You know how Blender has modifiers? It has that same feel.
Mark: I really don’t care what tools are used as long as they’re readily accessible and available. That’s one reason I eventually switched to Blackmagic. I don’t have a problem with commercial software, but it can’t be locked away where I have to have a subscription. That’s what I think Adobe does wrong. They should design their systems so that if I stop paying the subscription I can at least still open files and save out of them, even if I don’t get updates — not block people out completely.
The Story Is the Artists
Elevating Artists
Mark: I’ve had a couple of conversations with journalists who want to help me get the word out later, and with curators in the traditional art world — one in Canada, and the expert on Chinese contemporary art. The journalists in particular said I’ll have to tell my story. Their first instinct was: if I’m going to write this up, it has to be about you and how you started this.
I told them that’s really not what I want this to be about. The story isn’t me. The story is about the artists. In any advertising and any social media campaign I do, I want to show the artists. I want to elevate artists who in many cases have been working on their own and might not be well known — in addition, of course, to artists who might be known in a place like China but not in the United States or Europe. I want to elevate them to hero status.
Later, when we roll out the social media campaigns, that will also have the benefit of other artists looking and saying, “I’ve never heard of those artists before.” If they look the artists up, in many cases they won’t find much, and they’ll think, “Well, I’ll download this app, go into the museum and visit.” Then it’s our responsibility to make that a great experience. I’d also like to rotate what goes through there. A big part of our challenge is to do everything we can to promote the artists.
MetaHuman Videos and the Uncanny Valley
Mark: That’s also why I’m interested in doing those videos with MetaHumans: I want to cut a video like that every month, where we take time to present these artists to the world.
Chipp: I was watching something along that line recently. Someone took a video of a person talking — say you or me — and used that same voice; we can capture the voice easily, that’s not a problem. But then they created a stylized, already-rendered version of the person, so you didn’t get that uncanny valley feel. It’s just an interesting thought. That’s the problem with MetaHumans: they give a little too much. And I think my own videos have the same effect, because I’m using my cloned voice and it’s kind of stilted.
Mark: I didn’t notice that in the video where you said “you might have noticed that’s my voice.” I’ll tell you another story. I was doing a bunch of things — in some cases not even MetaHuman characters, but cloned characters in a realistic environment — and showing them to somebody who works at Blackmagic Design. I was explaining the different angles and talking about metadata, until I told them those weren’t real characters. They thought they were real. So I think sometimes we get in our own way. People may have a bit of an uncanny valley reaction, but as a result I can do something that looks like a million dollars in production value. I’m okay with a little uncanny valley reaction if it’s just the presenter, because the presenter isn’t that important. What’s important is the artists. The artists have to feel real.
So it’s a kind of contrast: the presenter gets to be a little chintzy and second rate, as long as any time we present an artist, with B-roll and so on, we present them like heroes. They need to look amazing. Obviously we don’t want to look like crap either, but that’s not as important to me.
Artist Photos on the Website
Chipp: I’m not crazy about putting the artist’s picture there. In an art gallery, if you see the artist’s picture at all, it’s a tiny picture off to the side somewhere.
Mark: Here’s why I’m doing it. Don’t consider this proper focus group research, but I talked with quite a few people, either showing them the app or at one of our meetups — artists are always bringing other artists. If they’d never heard of it before, they thought I was showing them AI art.
Also, have you heard the term “egoboo”? It’s an open source concept. One of the explanations for why people create open source was their own ego satisfaction. I want to tap into that a bit on the artist side. If an artist spends the time to put together 24 works, with no guarantee they’ll get in because it’s curated, and they do get in, then we will showcase them. We’ll do our part to promote them, whether through advertising or social media. That’s why I have it in there. We’ll also add standard fields with instructions about what kind of images they need, because they need to keep space free so that we can, for example, put a title on it. That’s the only reason.
Chipp: I understand. Then maybe just don’t make the artist the priority. You can use their face, but not their whole body, and make it smaller.
Mark: Like on the For Artists page at the bottom, where it’s in pink?
Chipp: On the For Artists page? Oh yeah. The blue is the artwork and the pink is — maybe that’s where they go.
Frames and the 3D Museum
The VR Experience
Chipp: I don’t know this, so tell me: isn’t there a VR walkthrough of some sort in this?
Mark: Not on the website — you have to download the app. Once you download it, you’re dropped immediately into a 3D environment, and you’re walking around. We only have three frames right now. They were modeled in Blender by an environment artist. The galleries aren’t perfect; there are so many things that could be improved, it’s not funny.
More Frame Choices
Chipp: If you want frames done, send me some pictures and I’ll run them through my 3D modeling skill, and you’ll get perfect frames. I’m happy to generate frames or anything like that for you, for the website or wherever — for instance a really ornate frame with a lot of filigree.
Mark: It would be more about what we offer artists as additional choices. Right now we’re not doing a great job of communicating those choices. It’s literally just a pull-down menu, and you typically don’t know what the frames look like, because there’s a difference between what’s in Unreal and what’s on the website — or in this case on Grow, the artist website. I’d definitely like more frames in the future.
Chipp: I’ve sent you some pictures.
Mark: I’m worried that those kinds of frames would distract people from the art.
Chipp: Yes and no; it depends. Framing is definitely an art in itself, as you may or may not know. I have a very ornate frame around a very colorful piece of art I did of the Joker and Harley Quinn. I also have a Peter Max — do you know who he is?
Mark: No.
Chipp: He’s a famous US artist, like Andy Warhol — a pretty famous guy. I have one of his pieces, a signed lithograph or whatever, with a really ornate frame, and the frame is just fantastic. I’m not saying that’s the perfect frame by any stretch, but there are definitely times and places for those kinds of frames. Let me copy this image. I’m pasting in some different frames so you can see. I may take one of these and use it for a website page or something; we’ll figure it out.
Mark: The frames we designed are extremely simple. One reason is that we’re concerned about how many artists we can get into an Unreal Engine project. The apps on different platforms have different size requirements. We’re hoping to get up to 1,200 artists in one app, though we may need to break things out into separate parts. We were very lucky to get a mentoring session or two from somebody who used to be a VP at Epic, and he explained that you can load content in and out, almost like chapters, because ultimately it’s a gaming engine. Anyway, one of our design parameters was how to keep a small footprint.
Chipp: I developed a pretty successful augmented reality app about the Alamo for San Antonio. It was a three-year project. I architected it and built the most accurate model of the Alamo in 1839 that ever existed, working with all these historians. It was a fun project. That was before my cancer, and I found out how much even a phone back then could handle. We used Unity, but Unreal has that voxelization, level-of-detail technology, which is just crazy. So I doubt very seriously any of these frames would be a problem for Unreal.
Mark: I’m all for expanding them, and if that’s part of the continuity, awesome. Right now we have a basic wooden frame, a basic black frame, and none — I wanted one that just looks like canvas. Those are the only three choices we currently give artists.
Platforms and Priorities
Mark: You have to remember we’re a two-person team, and we’re already on iPhone, iPad, Android phones, Android tablets and Meta Quest. The macOS version is going through TestFlight right now. That’s six devices. For PC I’m going through the Microsoft process; that’s device number seven. Vision Pro is going to happen in November; that’s eight different devices. That’s quite an accomplishment.
Chipp: I agree. That’s pretty significant.
Mark: But because of that, we’ve had to sacrifice some other things, and that’s where I’d now like to circle back and do this right. I really hate the navigation. I hate the UI in the actual application. There are things that burn my eyes. So I’m genuinely excited about working with you, and to have your skill set brainstorming with me to make this happen is amazing.
I also don’t want scope creep, to be clear. We originally talked about the website. But I feel it makes more sense to say from the beginning that this is about a cohesive design language that works on the website and in the app. I don’t want people to go to the website, say “this looks amazing,” download it, open the app and think, “What is this?”
Marketing Message and Headlines
What a Headline and Subhead Do
Chipp: Next, let’s talk about the marketing message in the brand. I’ll send you this page in Discord. Have you seen it before?
Mark: Yes, I fed it in when I did the redesign.
Chipp: So I already gave it to you. I’m going to go through this process and try to come up with headlines. Let me explain headlines. I sent you some links above — the bottom one, where the headline starts with six W’s.
The key thing to understand is that a headline grabs your attention, but it doesn’t need to be clickbait. Especially for a museum, clickbait is the last thing you want. You want something that grabs someone’s attention so they go, “Huh, that’s interesting.” Like the image you mentioned, “a place for curiosity.” That’s an interesting headline, because it makes you want to know what it’s about. Whereas the next one, “everyday extraordinary,” is more of a platitude — you could put it on almost any website. “A place for curiosity,” maybe not as much. We’d like something you can only put on our website, the Museum for a Rainy Day website.
The subheadline there, “objects, ideas and stories from a curious life,” isn’t a good one. The subheadline is where you provide evidence — something factual that establishes the headline isn’t just hoo-ha. It reinforces the headline, but not with more titillating, exciting verbiage. It tries to back it up, shore it up, make it stronger. So we’ll need a headline and a subheadline, and we’ll probably need some copy along the way too. I can walk you through how to generate those headlines.
The Landing Page Copy So Far
Mark: I went through various exercises — sometimes it feels like going in circles. This is early work I did with ChatGPT, trying to arrive at something.
Chipp: I’m looking at it: “a whole museum, wherever you are,” “walk through exhibitions by independent artists from around the world in our museum apps,” “discover their work anytime you feel like seeing art.” My challenge is that I still don’t know exactly what you’re about. “Ambition,” “free to choose your device.” It’s a lot better now, I have to say.
Mark: The one I’m showing you is early work. Then I fed this landing page workflow into Codex, I think, and added another layer on it. There’s a woman named Lulu Messervi — have you heard of her?
Chipp: No.
Mark: She’s apparently considered at the top of the game in corporate communications. She’s worked with Anduril and a ton of famous startups. She speaks very well and I like how she presents. One of her key ideas is something she calls “cultural erogenous,” and she has a methodology. So I overlaid her methodology onto your process, fed it some of our previous work, and that’s how it arrived at that.
Multi-Device: Strength or Gimmick?
Mark: It’s tricky. You said one of our greatest strengths, one of the things that makes us unique, is being on all these devices, and I agree. But at the same time that can sound like a gimmick. For me, the reason we’re on all those devices isn’t a gimmick; it’s because we want to make it accessible, in a way other museums don’t.
Two Audiences and the Chicken-and-Egg Problem
Chipp: I think you have a couple of problems. One is that you’re trying to appeal to at least two groups, maybe more: people who want to visit museums, and artists who want to show their wares in your museum. Is that correct?
Mark: Yes. That’s why we’re developing two experiences: the Museum for a Rainy Day, and Grow, the site artists go through. I did a competitive analysis of museum apps on the different platforms and figured out pretty quickly —
(Mark’s computer froze and he rebooted.)
Mark: Sorry, no idea what that was.
Chipp: Computers do what computers do.
Mark: I hadn’t restarted in a while, and I’m doing all kinds of weird stuff right now, so it might be that.
I was explaining that we have a chicken-and-egg problem. We want to build a great, compelling experience for people who want to see art, but there’s not much to look at unless we’re also building a platform that’s relatively straightforward for artists to upload and propose work.
The biggest challenge for many artists, from what I’ve gathered, is that not all of them have 24 works, and we require a minimum of 24. Part of that is because I want practicing artists — people who are really serious about creating art — so that’s part of our litmus test. And I believe it creates a better, more compelling experience for visitors, who can actually get a real feel for the artist. In my opinion that requires something like 24 works.
So we built both from the get-go. That was one of the issues I found in my competitive analysis of other museum apps: they don’t have an easy way to update. For museums it typically involves consultants or some kind of agency, so there aren’t many updates to those apps.
Early Meta Quest Results
Mark: We’ve barely been on the Meta Quest store two weeks, and we’ve already had 10,000 views on their platform and close to a hundred downloads. So even on what’s basically a gaming device, there’s interest in looking at art. Now imagine: they’ve downloaded the app, and we tell them it’s worth coming back because we’re bringing in new artists and new ways to visualize and present that art. That’s the reason.
Marketing Strategy
Chipp: 30% Development, 70% Marketing
Chipp: I may have already told you this, but I’ll say it again. One issue you have, that I have, and that almost every Blender developer has, is that we’re far more interested in developing cool technology and using tools than in marketing our products.
Mark: I am interested in marketing.
Chipp: Are you really?
Mark: I’m genuinely interested in marketing.
Chipp: Okay. I always tell everyone I’ve been around the block a few times, and it appears to me the equation is something like 30% development, 70% marketing. The way I defend that: go into Walmart or Target and look at the wall. There’s just a bunch of schlock up there — crap. You talk about AI slop; there’s a lot of non-AI slop in Target, and it’s making somebody a nickel. So it’s not just about building a better mousetrap. It’s about building a better mousetrap and then marketing the hell out of it. That will be a challenge.
I understand you have to have a place for people to go, but no one wants to put their art there because nothing’s there. I understand that whole catch-22. My thought is that it can be resolved with some smart marketing ideas. For example, work with galleries — not a famous one, but maybe start with a local gallery and ask, “When’s your next big gallery show?” Then put it into your app, show up there with a couple of headsets, and let people walk around. That’s just one idea, but there are a bunch of ideas like that for getting people to show up. Or figure out a way to use AI to help market their products.
To give an example: I released Illustration Station yesterday, last night. I haven’t done any marketing yet, but I talked to the Blender Market — Superhive — folks, and they said what I need to do is collaborate with them on one of my videos. When we collaborate, all of their users and all of my users see the same video, and they promote it on their website.
Mark: Oh, that’s interesting. I didn’t know that.
Chipp: That might be another thing — some collaborations in the media space, I don’t know. My point is that that’s how I think you’d solve that particular problem.
Mark: The Indifference of the Universe
Mark: I agree with you. I’ve been explaining this to Alex. I realized it the first time we ever released apps under my old company, and with other products I’ve done — this is ultimately my sixth venture, with one company still fully running. There’s what I call the indifference of the universe to your great idea, and that’s where we are right now.
I’m not worried about the marketing side. There are various ways to get attention for this. The moment we release on the Apple Vision Pro, for example — it’s a very tight community. I’m already connected with some people in the Unreal Engine world, because I went to some of the Unreal shows. So I’ll be working the technical angle, the press angle, all of that.
What I am worried about is that right now it’s the quiet before the storm. I have the indifference of the universe to this idea. I want something that’s tight: a website that clearly communicates what this is and why people should download it, and a user interface and design language that’s coherent. I think that will help tremendously when I run around showing it to people. As you said with your logo criticism, I’m approaching people who have an eye for things, and if it’s not tight, my job becomes much harder. That’s where I’m focused right now, and what I’d like to get solved.
Once that’s up and running — I’ve already explained this to Alex — I’ll be switching roles, and I’m assuming the majority of my time will be on the marketing and PR side. That’s why I’ve been building so many tools for both artist identification and recruitment, which I haven’t fully activated yet. I actually have bots researching artists and pulling lists of who I might want to contact, and I’m building a similar thing for a press list. That’s what my entire Outreacher tool is for.
Outreacher
Mark: Did I show you Outreacher? It’s my own internal tool. It’s a series of tools. This part tracks actual meetups. Right now I’m testing the format in Berlin: every couple of months I bring in artists and invite other artists, as a networking opportunity. It’s happening in Berlin, but I hope to eventually make it a standard format other people can take to other cities. It’s an opportunity to connect, and also to learn about the Museum for a Rainy Day.
The more serious part of Outreacher is on the right side. What you see here with the website or LinkedIn is where it started, but it isn’t limited to LinkedIn. For example, this one down here started as an app tour, but I can click inside it and it becomes a LinkedIn authoring tool. So I’m building the infrastructure that later lets me quickly write various posts and messages and then track them. A little orange dot means that version is finalized and done.
So, going back to whether I’m more interested in building tools or in executing: I like building tools, ultimately because I know that once I fully switch to this role, I need tools in place to push it.
Mark: This is another one. I’ve set it on identifying artists according to criteria. I occasionally change my mind, but this is the kind of thing it’s finding. The way the system is designed, if I delete someone, they’re out — they won’t even be approached. Otherwise I can approve them, which adds them to a certain queue. If I promote them, it adds them to my CRM for heavier follow-up.
Chipp: Good idea.
Chipp: So my concern was that you’d said you’re in this catch-22, but you were just explaining where you are, not asking for a solution. You know the solution. Okay, that’s fine.
Critique of the Current Website and App Imagery
The Homepage Image
Chipp: Let’s continue with the website. I just put some things in Discord. The top image is terrible. It’s not even halfway good. If I saw that image, I would never want to put on a pair of goggles and go there. Never. There are so many issues with it. One is that it doesn’t look real at all. It looks like the most basic 3D you can do.
Mark: Unfortunately, that’s the app experience right now.
Chipp: I know it is. I’m suggesting a few things. One is to focus some time and effort on making it look more like a real, beautiful museum. All you have to do is have Blender and MCP build it for you. Grab a bunch of pictures of an existing museum, have ChatGPT take all the pictures off the walls or put blank images in, then hand it to Blender and say, “Create the geometry from this.” It’ll build it for you with Opus 5.5.
Mark: We worked with Anthony Kimura, who used to work with Blender Guru and a bunch of other people. His design mandate was to build an environment that’s performant and works across all devices. That’s what he came back with: a nice modular system he built in Blender.
Chipp: He’s not an artist, I can tell you that. I guarantee he’s not a designer.
Mark: I suspect you’re right.
Chipp: You can make excuses; I’m just telling you.
Mark: No — that’s exactly the point. I don’t feel I need to make an excuse; if anything, I’d explain that it’s iterative. This was the best we could do in the timeframe we had. I agree with you. Right now we’re talking about a design language for the UI and the website, but if this stops you to the point where you say “we should fix this first,” then let’s fix it. But then I would need your help.
Cognitive Visualization and Framing
Chipp: We can talk about that. But look at this link I just sent you: cognitive visualization. When I work with a client, I always start there. You want to start with something exciting. The images on that page are cognitive visualizations. They’re not the final design; they’re something that gets people excited.
I’m not trying to pick on your designer. I’m trying to tell you that you have one chance to impress people. When they walk through the Louvre versus this gray building with poorly framed, poorly matted images on the walls — it just doesn’t work. I’ve also put in pictures of frames that are matted, and some with frames that relate to the image. I want you to understand that framing is a big part of it, and I think we can definitely do that. So yes, we need to update the website.
Order of Work
Mark: Can we stop for a second? That’s where I’m confused. We can go in any order you want; I’ll follow your lead. At no point am I saying no. I’m saying the opposite: this is where we are right now, and I just want to get better.
Chipp: I understand. Let’s do the branding first. We’re going to get rid of that image on your homepage, and I’ll generate an image I think looks a lot better. On the For Artists page you’ve added all these different colors. We need to update a bunch of this so people look at it and say, “That looks like a really interesting place. I’d like to promote my art there, or I’d like to visit it.” I think you’ll have more people wanting to promote. If you just do it right, people will want Grow more than they’ll want the Museum for a Rainy Day, if that makes sense.
Mark: That’s fine with me too.
Grow
Mark: I don’t want to get too much into Grow, because in the future there’s going to be a Grow Studio component, which is an optional subscription service. But even for Grow itself, I could send you design after design of ideas I have for features. I didn’t want to build a Facebook or a social network, because I hate the idea of people feeling compelled to post something — some people really get carried away with that. I liked the idea of something where artists can share what they’re working on and maybe creatively collaborate in different ways, but without it being too social-network-like. That’s why we call it a commons. But I don’t want to go off on this tangent.
Chipp: I agree. I think Grow has real potential.
Mark: Especially because I’ve already built features into it. I was talking with two curators about it: I want to build tools for people who can choose to build something — basically an exhibition — and then say, “I want to deploy this in the Museum for a Rainy Day,” or take it in some other direction, whether a completely separate app or just an organizational tool for them. Ultimately, the work has to be showcased somewhere.
At the very least I’d like the Museum for a Rainy Day to exist. I think it’s an important option that doesn’t exist. The idea of people having a permanent exhibition is unprecedented on its own. And it’s one that isn’t as gatekept. The litmus test is: are you practicing? Are you continuously putting out work? Is there a consistent style? If so, you have a very good chance of making it into the museum.
Chipp: I like that idea too.
Mark: But I don’t have a favorite child. If Grow is more successful than the Museum for a Rainy Day, that’s fine. I just feel this needs to exist. That’s what we’re building.
The Gallery Screenshots
Chipp: I keep looking at these damn pictures. These 3D images are just so yucky. We’ll figure that out; I’m not going to mess with it now.
Mark: I’m sure you’ll want to change the actual experience in the museum itself, and Alex and I are completely good with that. It’s just that we are where we are right now because that’s what we were able to do.
Chipp: I understand. So let’s make it better.
Why the Project Matters
“How Does This Make Money?”
Mark: Hopefully you think this is a worthwhile project. I have a business background — I’ve started and run several companies, so I have a business hat — but what almost annoys me is that a lot of people’s first question is, “How does this make money?” Can’t we build things every once in a while that are worth building just because they should exist?
Chipp: I think that was the first thing out of my mouth last conversation, and you basically said that’s not the point of this. That’s fine. Well, it is a point — it’s just not the primary point right now. At some point it might be. If you were trying to get investors, you’d have to answer that question a lot more clearly.
There are a lot of ways to look at things. The way I prefer is to be the leaf in the river: wherever the river takes you, you take advantage of that opportunity. As opposed to being the laser beam focused on the wall, where that’s where you’re headed and nothing will keep you from getting there. Both approaches are valuable, but one emphasizes the journey a bit more. That’s why I’m retired and doing all the fun stuff I do: it’s a journey. If it were just about making money, I’d be creating some kind of stock market app I could sell or use to generate revenue.
Mark: Just buy SpaceX at this point. It’s not that hard anymore.
Chipp: We’ll see what happens with the election. You saw where Elon posted, basically, “if you want more, come and get it.”
Mark: Elon’s crazy, but what he’s doing is phenomenal and amazing — the technical problems he’s trying to solve, and his entire land grab out there.
Mark: This Should Exist
Mark: The point I was trying to make is that you can’t believe how ecstatic I am that you’re excited about this project, because I think that’s the most important thing. I’m excited about it too. There are things here that don’t entirely make sense to the business part of my brain, but I feel this has to exist. I think it will help a lot of people be seen, and that’s a worthy goal on its own.
I suspect that if it’s successful and gets any traction, over time there is a business here, with some opportunities for revenue. I think I told you my research showed that museums typically make only about 20 to 25% of their revenue through ticket sales; they have all kinds of other revenue streams. That’s what I think the museum will be like, and Grow will be like the other things we do. So I think it’s possible to build something sustainable, but it’s not about that.
Even when I was researching taking investors, I looked not necessarily at who’s most successful but at who might be the best fit. There’s Caterina Fake — she started Flickr, then became part of Etsy, and is now, I think, one of the investors in Kickstarter. She’s a designer. That’s the kind of person I’d gravitate to if I actually wanted investment money, because people need to understand this isn’t about a 10x or 100x return. That’s not this kind of project. It’s: can we do something good and helpful for people who want to create art? Can we do something cool and worth downloading?
The interesting thing about the Meta Quest — and I think it’s why we’re getting so many downloads, which surprises us, and I think it’ll be even more so on the Vision Pro — is that there just isn’t much cool stuff there. It’s mostly gaming companies, or one-off projects where a museum hires somebody to build something, and after that the app is basically dead. So can we build something — with the Grow infrastructure also in place — where there’s life, where it evolves and continues to evolve? Where people just think, “I want to look at some art right now,” or “I want to be taken somewhere I’m not.” I want my mind to be expanded a little — not through Instagram doomscrolling, but by dedicating a couple of minutes to look at something that might leave an impression on me, take me somewhere else, relax me, or help me expand my mind a little. I think that should exist.
Other Art Sites
Chipp: You’ve looked at the other art sites where people post their work, right?
Mark: Every time I talk to somebody, they point me at new stuff. So I’ll say yes, but probably not all of them.
Chipp: One of the oldest is Renderosity. I used it. Have you heard of it?
Mark: No, never heard of it.
Chipp: It’s been around a long time. And ArtStation, of course.
Mark: But ArtStation is primarily a portfolio site for people who want to get hired in the gaming or concept art industry. That’s actually what I was getting at earlier. I went to a gaming conference in the UK to identify and talk with artists who make gaming assets and whom I knew were capable artists. I hoped some of them would show me things they do on the side where they’re creating just art. It turns out very few are. But of the ones who were, one woman showed me lace designs she’d done in Adobe’s 3D Substance Painter — just incredible work. It wasn’t on her portfolio site. If I hadn’t talked to her, I would never have seen it; it was a personal project she wanted to create. I hope to find more spirits like that, more people in the 3D space who might be squirreling things away the way she was. That’s the kind of work I hope will eventually make its way to the Museum for a Rainy Day.
Chipp: DeviantArt has been around forever too. Have you heard of it?
Mark: I’m aware of it. The tricky thing about those sites — DeviantArt in particular — is that they’re upload sites, and the Museum for a Rainy Day is curated. It’s like a DJ at a party: the DJ might play a song from the 1980s, like Michael Jackson’s “Thriller,” followed by a song that came out yesterday, but ultimately he makes sure people are entertained and find something they connect with. But yes, there was cool stuff on DeviantArt for sure.
Chipp: ArtStation has good people too. I hired a woman there to do a painting of the Alamo for me. It cost me a couple thousand dollars, but it turned out really good. It wasn’t for the project; it was an art piece I wanted to give my client, who had spent millions of dollars on this product. At the end I just gave him this painting. My point is there are good people on ArtStation doing things other than concept art.
The reason I bring it up: you said people might want to spend a little time looking at art. When I want to do that, where do I go? Places like ArtStation or Renderosity, somewhere that curates. Even BlenderArtists.org has a curated section — if something makes it to the top-level list, it’s somewhat curated. And you can subscribe to artists, so any time they put something new up, you see it.
Mark: Interesting. Some cool stuff on there.
Apps Versus the Web
Why Mark Started with Apps
Chipp: You definitely have a website component where you can look at the curated art — visit, I guess, is the right word. Can you do it from a webpage?
Mark: This is a webpage, but it’s only for me.
Chipp: No, I mean the Museum for a Rainy Day.
Mark: One reason I want to start with apps is that I wanted to build a project that could last essentially forever without costing too much money — without my wife freaking out about how much I’m spending. One advantage of apps is that I’m not paying distribution costs. I only do a one-time upload to the respective stores whenever we update. From then on, Apple, Google and whatever stores I upload to pay for the downloads. Since I don’t have traditional web traffic, that significantly cuts costs and makes the project more sustainable.
We’re of course looking at Three.js in particular, and we’re very interested in doing that in the long run. Cloudflare has some pretty exciting things going on, so I think I could add a web component at some point, but storage could also be an issue long term. For now I want to stick with the apps.
Also, what’s cool about having built it on Unreal Engine is that we’re piggybacking on its infrastructure, and Unreal has all these interesting targets — Apple TV, for example. Once the Apple Vision Pro version is out, the next thing we’ll cycle to is Apple TV, the actual set-top box.
Navigation in the App
Chipp: Here’s my thought. I don’t think the idea is exciting enough to live as an Unreal-Engine-only app. Walking through a gallery is wonderful the first and second time, but the fourth or fifth time you might just want to scroll through a page.
Mark: Well, you can. Do you have an iPad nearby?
Chipp: No, I don’t use iPad. I don’t use anything Apple anymore.
Mark: What about Android? Do you have an Android tablet?
Chipp: Yes.
Mark: Then go to the Play Store and download the Museum for a Rainy Day. The first time you start it, it launches a video with a MetaHuman of me explaining the controls. One option is typical gaming thumb controls to navigate through a gallery. But most people will either tap an image and be taken immediately to it, or — most common — swipe: from the middle, left or right, you swipe through any gallery. To switch, you hit “gallery” at the top and move to the next one. So it’s immersive when you want it to be, but you can navigate perfectly well.
Storage and Image Treatment
Chipp: Where are you storing all that data?
Mark: It’s all in the app.
Chipp: So eventually the app will be gigabytes in size?
Mark: That’s why we wanted performance and very reduced galleries. We also spend a lot of ingenuity and time treating the images. I can’t ask artists to upload power-of-two images, but I need power-of-two images. So we do the best we can with smart compression and pre-processing and touching up of the images to make it all work and be performant.
Can a Website Handle It?
Chipp: And you can’t do that with a website? The amount of data you’d need to host isn’t the issue, because it’s curated images. The issue is probably the number of simultaneous hits you’d get.
Mark: I happen to be in this business. My company runs Metro Publisher, a CMS used by small city and regional magazines, niche publications and so on. I can tell you right now their sites are getting hammered by bot traffic, and it’s a real challenge to keep it all up and running. I started on this project more than a year ago — Alex came a little later, when I began sketching out ideas — and if you’d asked me six months ago whether a website was possible, my answer would have been no; the numbers said it wasn’t possible. Now, with Cloudflare, I do think it’s possible to have a web component without being too concerned. However, even Cloudflare starts to cost money when you have lots and lots of images.
The other thing for me is that I want an experience that can scale to different devices. Without a doubt, the most awesome way to experience the Museum for a Rainy Day is on a Vision Pro or a Meta Quest. Right now Alex is experimenting in Unreal Engine with something like a beanstalk — an endless beanstalk showing different art, and you can jump from the beanstalk into other art. He’s also experimenting based on our analysis of a company that has since exited the market but had a pretty cool visualization experience for images: basically an endless frame of images, where you click on one, it expands, and you can go to another. So we have many different ideas for presenting the art, because that will be one of the challenges once we have, say, 1,200 artists. How do you even handle “click the next gallery”?
Chipp: My thought is that you take steps before you start running. That’s a challenge for you, because you have so much experience in this space that you’re thinking, “I need to architect this for a hundred thousand images,” when right now you don’t need to. If it costs as much time and effort to build and market it for a hundred thousand as for a thousand, then maybe it’s a good thing. But I think you could create something immediate that gets people excited right off the bat, on a webpage using WebGL — most likely Three.js would be the technology, and you probably know what it is. Then you can say: “If you think this is cool, wait till you see it on Meta Quest or on the Apple device.” That’s just me thinking out loud.
Mark: Real quick: I’m not in disagreement. If you’d asked me a couple of months ago, I’d have told you the math says no — like the Little Britain sketch, “computer says no.” But since then I’ve done deeper research and some new things have popped up, so I think it is possible. At a certain point, though, you make design decisions and have to follow that path before you can do the next thing.
Chipp: I understand that.
Mark: Right now we’re wedded to Unreal Engine, and we’re thinking about how to use it, as the cool gaming engine it is, to present art in completely different ways that can only be done in Unreal Engine.
Meta Quest Store Exposure
Mark: What I wouldn’t underestimate is the Meta Quest data alone: 10,000 people have now seen the Museum for a Rainy Day within that system, for free.
Chipp: That’s the first time I’ve heard that. Is that 10,000 unique viewers? 10,000 downloads?
Mark: No — 10,000 unique people have seen it, for free. I didn’t spend a cent on that, and I didn’t spend a cent on the downloads, and 85 people have downloaded.
Chipp: How do you get 10,000 unique viewers and only 85 downloads?
Mark: Because the Meta Quest store suggests things you might want to download, and it has these title cards. People scroll through, and for 10,000 users one of those will have been our title card. To me that’s free advertising. And the Meta Quest store has remarkably little that isn’t gaming. I’m not saying those are amazing numbers, but thank you, Facebook.
A month from now we’ll do the same thing for Vision Pro, which has even fewer apps. There I’ve built a very solid list. The first thing I’ll do once we launch is reach out to YouTubers who cover the Vision Pro and really work that angle, to try to activate their bases. I think this is a unique opportunity. If we were on the web, we’d be one of a million people doing something like this. There’s much more on the web.
Chipp: I hear that. I’m trying to look at conversion. Maybe it’s not that important. Maybe this is just a landing page that converts to something else. Eventually — it’s not something you need to do now.
Unreal Talent and Lighting
Who Can Make It Look Good
Chipp: Here’s what I’d suggest. I’m going to generate some of these concepts, and they’ll have different treatments for your gallery. Do you have a really good Unreal Engine artist?
Mark: No. I struggled with that in the beginning.
Chipp: Good artists really understand the rendering side of the engine. I got good at figuring out how to render in Unity when I was doing the Alamo project — all the settings for global illumination and the different lighting models.
Mark: Oh, you mean the technical part? Alex went from zero in Unreal Engine; he’s nerded out on it. And to Unreal Engine’s credit, it’s fantastic now about having a proper MCP integration. 5.9 literally rolled out yesterday with even better integration. Those things we can solve.
Chipp: Does Alex have a website?
Mark: No — Alex is a partner in my regular company. He’s a full-stack developer.
Chipp: Sorry. Who’s the guy who did the environment?
Mark: Anthony Kimora. Hold on, I should be able to find it quickly. I’ll share a video with you in a minute. I actually had to rein him in at one point, because he was going too modular. In fairness, the mandate was performance — nothing too crazy, not too many advanced Unreal technologies. What I’ve been arguing with Alex is that more than anything, we probably need a lighting artist. I dropped in the link. He has one of those footers that’s a graphic, so there’s no link in it.
Chipp: Is this stuff done in Twinmotion? I know Twinmotion. Is there any UE work on here, or is it all Twinmotion?
Mark: He turned around an Unreal Engine level for us.
Chipp: Twinmotion is based on Unreal Engine.
Mark: As is Fortnite.
Chipp: That’s pretty good modeling and good texturing. The question is, I don’t see any environment work there.
Mark: No. He’s built a couple of successful plugins. He recently launched a really cool Unreal Engine plugin for pipes, where you can modify the pipes. It’s not rocket science, but he did a really nice job, and I think it’s selling pretty well, so I think he’ll go further in that direction. I’d been hunting for a while; I met him at Unreal Fest in Stockholm, and out of the people I’d talked to he seemed the most solid. I was glad for the help. You know how it is.
Chipp: I know how it is. I just want to understand what we’re dealing with. I see now he’s not an environment guy. He does products, and he does a nice job with the modeling, and the texturing looks pretty good too. But I don’t know that he’s a guy who can light. The challenge you have is, one, there’s no interest at all in the images, and two, the lighting is terrible. The lighting and the textures are terrible in the images I’m seeing on your website. And the camera angles. You have one decent camera angle, looking down the wall.
Lighting Is an Artistic Skill
Chipp: You’re right that with MCP and Unreal Engine you can probably figure out how to control lighting. What you can’t figure out is the art of it. I recently watched a video by a CG/VFX guy comparing what he can do in VFX with what AI can do, at $10, $100, $1,000 and $10,000. At $10 you get a Fiverr guy, and he does a shitty job on VFX, and for $10 the AI does a shitty job too. At $10,000 it was him: “This is what I would do for $10,000.” They were all doing the same dinosaur shot. Then for AI he went to Higgsfield — you know Higgsfield?
Mark: Yeah. It’s like the best.
Chipp: They have built-in workflows, Seedance and all that. He was right that his work looked better than the Higgsfield output. But what he missed is that if I gave the top $50,000 worth of hardware, software and compositing engines to an intern and said “create this video,” it would have been crap. It doesn’t matter. Going to Higgsfield is the same thing. I have friends who’ve done 50 films — I think you’ve seen some of their work — and while I’m trying to figure out how to make one advertisement, one of them does a much better job in an afternoon, because he understands that business.
So my point is that even if you can control Unreal Engine with MCP, it doesn’t mean you know how to light it. Lighting isn’t a technical skill; it’s an artistic skill. Just like with video: I couldn’t do those videos because I didn’t have that language, and as much as I tried to learn it, I still didn’t have it. I could probably control Unreal Engine lighting only because I know a lot about the technology and I know specifically what I’m looking for. You might be able to do it too if you have a reference image: “This is my reference image. See if I can replicate it in Unreal.”
Mark: What helps is that as part of my photography education, I interned for six months at one of the largest studios in the Washington, D.C. area, which had four studios inside. Everything you could imagine was shot there. I was the guy handing out the equipment, watching people set it up and asking questions. So I have a good idea of how light can be modified, but that still doesn’t make me a lighting artist. Maybe I speak more of that language, but I still don’t necessarily speak it.
I’m very well versed in networking technologies and cloud stuff. You can ask me any question there and I can find the answer, and I probably have somebody in my Rolodex to solve the problem. But for Unreal Engine I’ve essentially had to build that network from scratch — after spending some time learning Blender, where I might have made a contact or two. But some of the Blender people I spoke to said, “I don’t do Unreal Engine.” So I suspect part of our ongoing work, and one of the challenges, will be expanding the network and bringing in the right person. I spent a couple thousand on Anthony to build that level, so it’s not like I was being super cheap.
Chipp: I understand. And that’s not my goal either.
Mark: As for the money: whether it’s $500 or a bit more, whatever I can squeeze into my budget, I’m so insanely grateful just to get your feedback. The idea of you applying your design experience to help build a unified language that feels cohesive for the museum — where people can tell this is a serious endeavor worth checking out, whether they’re an artist or the public — means the world to me. And you’ve identified it correctly. I’ve had these back-and-forths with Alex specifically about lighting. I said, “I think we need a lighting artist,” and he said, “Let me try to tweak this a little more with the MCP.” He’s doing the best he can.
Composition Problems in the Screenshots
Chipp: I assume you’re looking at the pictures I just pasted into Discord. If you’re a photographer, you know immediately what’s wrong. Forget the lighting for a second; you can look at those three pictures and tell exactly what’s wrong.
Mark: The leading lines are bad.
Chipp: There’s no focal point, no area of interest. The perspective is just crazy bad. You’d want to use — what do they call it — the correction that keeps verticals vertical when you take a picture. You don’t want that three-point vanishing look.
Mark: What’s interesting, though, is the screen dimensions, not the resolution. The one at the top is, I’m pretty sure, an Android device, and that’s not 16 by 9 — I’m assuming it’s 16 by 10 — versus the iPad’s 4 by 3. It’s kind of tricky.
Chipp: But all you’re trying to do is get a beautiful picture for this one image on a website. They’re all terrible from a lighting standpoint, and they’re also all terrible in composition. The bottom one was taken just so you can see the roof — “look at all the detail we put into the model and the roof.” But the whole point of the roof is to disappear. When you build a gallery like that, you paint it all black so nobody pays attention to it. Yet that’s what the image focuses on: the beams on the roof have the most detail, so your eye goes right to them.
Mark: I suspect the goal of those images was to show that it’s a three-dimensional space. But I agree with you.
Chipp: Put your thinking hat on: how else could you show it’s a three-dimensional space?
Mark: In this case we have three different angles.
Chipp: You could put a wireframe over half of it. Take the right third and turn it into a wireframe, and all of a sudden people say, “Oh, that’s three-dimensional. That’s not a photograph.” I’m just suggesting those are options.
Mark: I agree. It’s like we have a million construction sites. What I’d like to do is work through them in some kind of sequence. We can start with the app; I’ve got no problem with that.
Chipp: No, we’ll start with the website.
Mark: Would you rather do the app first, because you’re going to need it?
Chipp: Not really. Let me tell you why. It’s because of that link I sent you on cognitive visualization.
Next Steps
Chipp’s Plan for the Next Week
Chipp: Here’s where I am. We’ll meet next week — same time, same channel, if you’re available — and I’ll forward you some things in the meantime.
Mark: Yes.
Chipp: I’ll work on branding and design concepts between now and then. Branding is going to be logo, color theme, typography and design. I’m not going to do messaging yet; we’ll get to that later. I might do some sample messaging, but let’s not focus on it yet — it’s easy to add as we go. The design concepts aren’t finished designs, just ideas.
I’m going to take a lot of what you already have, at least for the typography, and try to update it. I think we need one more font. I like your font selection, by the way — the high x-height and the condensed fonts are really nice. I like that quite a bit. That said, it’s a little informal, so I might try one with Futura or something a bit more formal. We’ll see. I need to do some research.
The Aspirational Approach
Chipp: If I did for you what the person in that cognitive visualization link did, the very first thing I’d do is generate a bunch of images. In the past I’d generate quick radiosity-style renderings, or grab images off Google, color them up and tweak them in Photoshop. Now I’ll just ask ChatGPT and Midjourney to generate those images for us, because that’s what you want: something aspirational at that level.
Before you put a single polygon in the scene, you want something aspirational — not something where you say, “We had to make it this way; there are too many polygons for that,” and so on. You want something aspirational, and then you figure out how to do the technology on top of it. That’s what design thinking is all about. That’s what Steve Jobs did: if you ask people what they want on a smartphone, they’ll tell you right away they want bigger buttons. But that’s not what we do. We need to take a step back and figure out how people will use it. We need the product to be aspirational.
That’s the typical industrial design or design thinking model: you start at the cognitive visualization stage, where you want something aspirational that gets people excited about what they’re working on. It doesn’t mean the end product will be exactly what we show, but it does mean that’s what we’re shooting for — that or something better, hopefully. So that’s what I’ll be shooting for in the next stage: something aspirational.
Closing
Mark: Awesome. I’m fully on board, however long it takes, within the confines of however much time you have available.
Chipp: Good. Mark, those are the two things I’m working on for next week, and we’ll get something going for you. Good discussion, and thanks for joining. This is fun stuff. I enjoy working on projects like this. This should be fun.
Mark: That’s awesome.
Chipp: Okay, Mark, I’m going to let you go. Good discussion — we had a good time. We got a couple of hours in. Talk to you later.
Mark: Bye.