Nov 2, 14:03
Payment and Opening Housekeeping
- Patreon to be replaced by PayPal for payment
- Patreon takes a big cut
- Money held for over a month
- URL sent in Discord: Museum for Rainy Day website design review and redesign
- AI-generated document, partly corrected by hand
- Asks for detailed review of executive summary, customer value proposition, at-a-glance part
Project Goals
Goals for Working Together
- Client not a designer; generalist, serious about photography only
- Wants cohesive identity and design language across app and website
- Wants it to feel professional
- Open to bringing in other help if needed
Goals for the Museum
- Started as a place to show own photography
- Doesn’t post photos online; avoids feeding Instagram and AI
- Museum or gallery context feels different
- Extend to other diligent, unseen artists
- Example: Todd Kohnstein, Berlin painter; house full of paintings
- Shown only five or six times, in cafés
- Permanent exhibitions for at least 1,200 artists across many devices
- Best on MetaQuest or Vision Pro; decent on iPad, iPhone
- Long-term: serious digital museum including 3D artists
- Blender competitions, ArtStation game-asset artists lack such an outlet
- Should be serious, but cool and fun
Revenue and Grow
- Revenue secondary for now; costs kept very low
- Future special exhibits
- Talks with curator of contemporary Chinese art; ex-Sotheby’s, now Confucius Institute Nuremberg
- Grow, sister site: tools for curators and artists, some free, some paid
- Platform to propose work and have it reviewed
- Output mainly to Museum for Rainy Day, possibly other digital museums
Designer’s Summary of Needs
- Help with branding and website design
- Customers: visitors plus 3D and traditional artists, and the client’s photography
Meeting Record and Questions Page
- Designer will post a synopsis after each meeting on a webpage
- Same page will hold questions for the client
- Fields and buttons; “CopyJSON” button top right
- Copy and send result via Discord
Halloween Aside
- Client in Spain; wife is Spanish
- Few children out on the paseo on Halloween
- Client half American, half German
Logo Critique
Logotype
- Pixelated type reads as youth, gaming or rave
- Only color is four green dots; looks like a mistake
- Users get no chance to hear the logo explained
- Brand not recognizable anywhere yet
- Name liked: communicates the idea and sparks curiosity
- Logo mark (umbrella with green raindrops) can work; logotype questioned
- Suggests considering a change; client’s choice
Client’s Reasons for the Logo
- Trademark applications already filed
- Pixelation signals gaming technology and digital nature
- Name alone may not say “digital museum”
- Didn’t want to get caught up on the logo early
- Partly agrees; logotype can evolve later
Criticism Style and Priorities
- Client half German; welcomes blunt, constructive criticism
- Agrees with earlier point: no designer ever touched the website
- Prefers to prioritize cohesive design language over logo work
Logo at Small Sizes
- Shared Photoshop view of logo in Discord
- 72 DPI too low for such a complex logo
- Idea: use logo mark with name set beside it
- Font and logo look fine large, like a title card; design pass made them too small
- Umbrella alone at 512 x 512 used as icon; acceptable small
- Designer asks for the logo font
- Serious kerning issues in “for a rainy day”
- Audience is artists with aesthetic sensibility; logo is first thing seen
- Designer will rework it and suggest other ideas
Color Palette
- Current green close to British racing green; not liked
- Designer had an MGB as a kid
- Designer asks for a mood board
Mood Board Approach
- Tools: PureRef, Photoshop, Google Slides
- Source sites: Behance, website design galleries
- Paste images straight into Discord
- Client wants to build a mood board app in Grow
- Designer’s own approach: evaluate from designer, marketing, curator, artist viewpoints
- Personal likes welcome even if not copied
- Example: favorite camera, sports-car connection
- Semantic inquiry: if the company were an animal, food, celebrity spokesperson
- Aim: avoid designer doing what fits him but not the client
Client’s Look-and-Feel Wishes
- Not in love with Tate or MoMA sites
- Avoid looking too technology-driven; logotype is the nod to tech
- Licensed logo font; D-Din (open source) used for museum signage
- Sophisticated, but not overly museum-like or institutional
- More accessible
- Curation not based on followers, sales or exhibition counts
- Looks for artists regularly practicing in their field
- Cameras would feel too technical as a model
- Must be clear it is a digital museum
- Colors chosen to complement and break up layouts
- Avoid “Windows tile” look across artist panels
Designer’s Color Guidance
- Large areas of color will overwhelm the art
- Checks client knows hue, saturation, value; color schemes
- Suggests whites and grays, maybe muted colors
- Option: clean, monochromatic, playful interior
- Logo is playful
- Colorful front image that rarely changes, or art matching the theme
Story Focus on Artists
- Journalists and curators urge client to tell his own story
- Curators: one in Canada, one Chinese contemporary art expert
- Client: story is the artists, not him
- Elevate little-known artists to hero status
- Includes artists known in China but not in US or Europe
- Social campaigns draw other artists to download and visit
- Rotate featured artists
- Monthly MetaHuman videos presenting artists
Presenter Videos and Uncanny Valley
- Designer saw voice cloning paired with a stylized rendered person
- MetaHumans can feel off; designer’s own cloned voice sounds stilted
- Client’s story: Blackmagic Design contact thought cloned characters were real
- Client accepts some uncanny valley for high production value
- Presenter unimportant; artists must feel real and look like heroes
- Designer trying to generate images live; results poor
- Midjourney good for concept work
- Client likes “a place for curiosity” image; keeps returning to black, dislikes it
- Problem: works with 2D images, not 3D
- ChatGPT best for marketing copy and headlines; good for refining imagery
- Designer will build a website of ideas
Logo Direction Decision
- Client agrees with logo and type criticism
- Proposes using the umbrella alone as logo; rest in regular type
- Designer agrees
Umbrella Changes
- Designer wants to add a green dot on the far right
- Client: a new trademark variation adds cost
- Quoted as “a thousand, $500”
Trademark Discussion
- Designer asks why trademark at all
- Client’s reasons
- T-shirts, tote bags, museum gift shop
- Talks with Chinese manufacturer on logo cases bundling apps
- Designer: money not well spent
- Only trademarked once, when investors demanded it
- TM mark may be usable without registration; look into it
- Dated public use also protects the image
- Client: money already spent; avoid sunk cost fallacy
- Client open to logo changes; keep pixelation, evolve gradually
- Designer: keep umbrella, add a dot, maybe add color
- Black-and-white version needed; client has one
- Umbrella works on white and black
Mood Board Assignment
- Mood board can come from Midjourney, ChatGPT or anywhere
- Client posts black-and-white logo and postcard design to Discord
- Designer asks about Affinity Designer; client uses it
- Designer rebuilding Photoshop clean-room with free AI features using ChatGPT subscription
- Designer rebuilding Inkscape, an open source Illustrator rival
- Path effects like Blender modifiers
- Client: any tool fine if accessible
- Switched to Blackmagic; dislikes Adobe subscription lock-out
Fonts and Logo Files
- Client to send D-Din, logo font and latest vectors
- Logo redrawn by a graphic designer friend after file loss
- Original pixelated, feathered; no perfect version
- Designer will do the mood board himself; only show what he likes
- Fundamental challenge: 2D art for now, 3D later
- Client loves robot images but has no 3D robot
- Designer focused on look, feel and color themes before headlines and type
- Robot idea could become a 3D picture frame holding 2D art
App and Frames
- App drops users straight into a 3D environment
- Three frame types, modeled in Blender by an environment artist
- Designer offers to generate frames with his 3D modeling skill
- Client: frames are choices for artists
- Currently a pull-down; artists can’t see frames
- Differences between Unreal and website, and Grow
- Two-person team
- iPhone, iPad, Android phones and tablets, MetaQuest
- macOS in TestFlight: six devices
- PC in Microsoft process: seven
- Vision Pro in November: eight
- Sacrifices made; client hates current navigation and UI
Scope
- Not meant as scope creep
- Design language must cover website and app
- Avoid great website followed by a disappointing app
Designer’s Own Brand Example
- chipwaters.com: teal and red-orange, a favored font
- Abstract tiles not literal product pictures
- Same brand on Patreon, Superhive, Gumroad, YouTube thumbnails
- Not identical everywhere, but continuous
- Client noticed the change; wants continuity between experiences
- Goal: logo, color theme, typeface
- Color is the strongest design element
- Volkswagen painted Ferrari red
- Typography huge; logo font too distinctive for reading
- Client: never intended for reading; D-Din for text
Fonts Delivered
- Client finds logo font in archive; D-Din in Git repo
- Two fonts dropped into Discord; designer confirms
Frames Revisited
- Client worries ornate frames distract from art
- Designer: framing is an art in itself
- Ornate frame on his Joker and Harley Quinn piece
- Signed Peter Max lithograph with ornate frame
- Client: simple frames to keep Unreal footprint small
- Target 1,200 artists in one app; may split into parts
- Ex-Epic VP mentor: load levels in and out like chapters
- Designer: built Alamo AR app for San Antonio
- Three-year project; most accurate 1839 Alamo model
- Used Unity; Unreal’s LOD tools make frames no problem
- Current frames: basic wood, basic black, none (canvas look)
- Designer pastes frame examples to Discord
Marketing Message and Headlines
- Client had already fed the landing page doc into the redesign
- Headline grabs attention without clickbait
- “A place for curiosity”: good, intriguing
- “Everyday extraordinary”: platitude, fits any site
- Headline should fit only this website
- Subheadline gives evidence backing the headline
- “Objects, ideas and stories from a curious life”: weak
- Need headline, subheadline and some copy
- Designer reads early copy; still unclear what museum is about
- Client: current version far better
Client’s Copy Process
- Fed landing page workflow into Codex
- Overlaid Lulu Messervi’s methodology
- Top corporate communications; worked with Anduril
- Multi-device presence can sound like a gimmick; real aim is access
Two Audiences
- Designer: appealing to visitors and to artists at once
- Client: two experiences, Museum for Rainy Day and Grow
- Competitive analysis of museum apps
- Connection drop; designer reboots
Chicken and Egg Problem
- Need compelling visitor experience and simple artist upload platform
- Minimum 24 works per artist
- Filters for practicing, serious artists
- Gives visitors a real feel for the artist
- Other museum apps hard to update; need consultants or agencies
- MetaQuest: two weeks, 10,000 views, close to 100 downloads
Marketing Advice
- Developers prefer building tech to marketing
- Designer’s rule: 30% development, 70% marketing
- Target and Walmart shelves full of junk that still sells
- Catch-22 solvable with smart marketing
- Partner with local galleries; bring headsets to shows
- Use AI to help market artists
- Superhive collaboration videos reach both audiences
- Illustration Station released last night
Client’s Marketing Plans
- Sixth venture; “indifference of the universe to your great idea”
- Not worried about marketing
- Tight Vision Pro community; Unreal contacts
- Technical and press angles
- Needs tight website and coherent UI first
- Will then switch roles to marketing and PR
- Bots researching artists; similar press list
- Internal tool tracking artist meetups
- Testing in Berlin every couple of months; future standard format
- Authoring and tracking for posts and messages, LinkedIn and beyond
- Orange dot marks a finished version
- Builds tools to push marketing later
- Designer: client already knows the solution
Website Imagery Critique
- Top website image terrible; looks like basic 3D
- Client: that is the current app experience
- Designer: make it look like a beautiful real museum
- Use Blender MCP with Opus 5.5 from museum photos
- Client: Anthony Kimura built modular, performant Blender environment
- Designer: not an artist or designer
- Client: work is iterative; open to fixing app first
Cognitive Visualization
- Designer shares cognitive visualization link
- Start with exciting images, not final design
- One chance to impress
- Poorly framed, poorly matted images don’t work
- Shared matted frame examples; framing matters
Order of Work
- Client confused about order; will follow designer’s lead
- Designer: branding first
- Replace homepage image with generated one
- For Artists page has too many colors
- People may want Grow more than the museum
Grow
- Future Grow Studio: optional subscription
- Many artifact design ideas
- Not a social network; avoid pressure to post
- Share work in progress, collaborate creatively
- Curator tools to build exhibitions
- Deploy to Museum for Rainy Day or elsewhere
- Permanent exhibition unprecedented; less gatekept
- Test: practicing, continuous output, consistent style
- No favorite child between Grow and the museum
Next Steps
- Meet next week, same time and channel
- Designer to work on branding and design concepts
- Logo, color theme, typography, design
- No messaging yet; maybe sample messaging
- Concepts are ideas, not finished designs
Typography Notes
- Designer likes client’s high x-height, condensed fonts
- A bit informal; may try Futura or something more formal
- Needs research
Artist Photos
- Designer dislikes prominent artist photos
- Galleries show a tiny photo off to the side
- Client’s reasons
- Meetup visitors thought they were seeing AI art
- “Ego boo”: tap artists’ ego satisfaction
- Reward for submitting 24 curated works; promotion promised
- Standard fields and image instructions coming
- Designer: smaller face photo, don’t prioritize the artist
- For Artists page: blue is artwork, pink is the artist area
App Experience
- Designer finds the 3D images unappealing
- Client and Alex open to changing the in-museum experience
Making Money vs. Worthwhile Projects
- Client annoyed when people first ask how it makes money
- Designer asked that last time; investors would need clearer answer
- Leaf in the river vs. laser beam; both valuable
- Designer retired, values the journey
- Aside: SpaceX, election, Elon Musk
Client’s View
- Thrilled designer is excited
- Project should exist; helps people be seen
- Business may come with traction
- Museums earn about 20 to 25% from tickets
- Possible investor fit: Caterina Fake
- Flickr, Etsy, Kickstarter; a designer
- Not about 10x or 100x returns
- MetaQuest and Vision Pro lack non-gaming content
- Museum apps usually die after launch
- Grow keeps the app alive and evolving
- Alternative to Instagram doom scrolling
Other Art Sites
- Renderosity, ArtStation, DeviantArt, BlenderArtists
- ArtStation mainly a hiring portfolio for games and concept art
- Client at UK gaming conference
- Few game artists make personal art
- One woman’s lace designs in Substance Painter
- DeviantArt is an upload site; museum is curated
- Curation like a DJ mixing old and new
- Designer hired an ArtStation painter for an Alamo painting
- Couple thousand dollars; gift to client
- Curated sections and artist subscriptions elsewhere
- Client’s tool finds artists by criteria
- Delete removes; approve queues; promote adds to CRM
Web vs. App Delivery
- Designer asks about viewing from a webpage
- Client chose apps for low cost, long life
- Stores pay distribution; one-time uploads
- No web traffic costs
- Looking at Three.js and Cloudflare long term; storage a concern
- Unreal targets include Apple TV; next after Vision Pro
- Designer: walking a gallery gets old; scrolling wanted
App Navigation
- Designer to download from Play Store on Android tablet
- First launch plays MetaHuman video explaining controls
- Gaming thumb controls, tap image to jump, or swipe
- Switch galleries via top menu
Data and Scale
- All images stored in the app
- Performance focus; reduced galleries
- Smart compression of power-of-two images
- Designer: issue is simultaneous hits, not data size
- Client runs Metro Publisher CMS; sites hammered by bot traffic
- Cloudflare now makes a web component possible, but costs grow
- Alex experimenting: endless beanstalk, endless image frame
- Challenge: navigating 1,200 artists
Designer’s Web Suggestion
- Walk before running; don’t architect for 100,000 images yet
- Quick Three.js webpage to excite people
- “If you think this is cool, wait till MetaQuest”
- Client agrees it’s possible now, but committed to Unreal
- MetaQuest: 10,000 unique people saw title card free; 85 downloads
- Store suggests apps; little non-gaming content
- Vision Pro next; outreach to Vision Pro YouTubers
- On the web it would be one of a million
- Designer focused on conversion; maybe landing page later
Unreal Artist and Lighting
- Designer will generate concepts with gallery treatments
- No good Unreal artist on the team
- Alex: full stack developer, partner in client’s company, learned Unreal
- Unreal 5.9 MCP integration improved
- Anthony Kimura: met at Unreal Fest Stockholm
- Twinmotion work; good modeling and texturing, no environments
- Successful Unreal pipe plugin
- Mandate: performance, few advanced features
- Client paid a couple thousand for the level
- Client thinks a lighting artist is needed
Lighting Is an Art Skill
- Website images: lighting, textures, camera angles bad
- VFX artist video comparing human vs. AI at $10 to $10,000
- Higgsfield output weaker than the expert’s
- Tools don’t help a novice; skill matters
- MCP control doesn’t mean knowing how to light
- Reference image approach could help
- Client interned six months at large D.C. photo studio
- Knows light modifiers, not a lighting artist
- Client strong in cloud and networking, built Unreal contacts from scratch
- Goal: expand network, bring in the right person
Client’s Gratitude
- Grateful for feedback at any budget, $500 or more
- Cohesive design language shows a serious endeavor
Gallery Screenshot Critique
- Bad leading lines, no focal point
- Bad perspective; verticals should stay vertical
- Aspect ratios differ: Android 16:10, iPad 4:3
- Bottom image shows off the roof beams
- Gallery ceilings should vanish, painted black
- Client: images meant to show a 3D space
- Designer: wireframe overlay on right third shows 3D
Work Sequence and Aspirational Concepts
- Client: many construction sites; work through in sequence
- Designer: start with website
- Cognitive visualization first: aspirational images before any polygons
- Generate with ChatGPT and Midjourney
- Then solve the technology
- Design thinking; Steve Jobs and the smartphone example
- Next stage goal: something aspirational
- Client fully on board, at whatever pace
Wrap-Up
- Good discussion, about two hours